Hollingsworth v. Virginia

Decided Supreme Court of the United States
Disposition
dismissed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Not specified
Decided
Judge
The Court
Posture
Suit against a state where defendant never entered an appearance
Plaintiffss (2)
Hollingsworth, et al.
W. Tilghman, Rawle
v.
Defendant (1)
Virginia
Lee, Attorney General

Overview

The Court unanimously held that the Eleventh Amendment, being constitutionally adopted, deprived the Court of jurisdiction in any case where a state was sued by citizens of another state, including cases pending at the time of adoption. The judgment was that the Court could not exercise jurisdiction in such cases.

Case summary

Hollingsworth v. Virginia (1798) was a landmark Supreme Court case addressing the Eleventh Amendment's effect on pending lawsuits against states. After the Court's decision in Chisholm v. Georgia (1793) allowed citizens to sue states in federal court, Congress proposed and states ratified the Eleventh Amendment to overturn this ruling. The case involved a suit against Virginia by citizens of another state that was pending when the amendment was adopted. The plaintiffs argued the amendment should not apply retroactively and that it was improperly proposed without presidential approval. The Court unanimously held that: (1) the Eleventh Amendment applies retroactively to all suits against states, including pending cases, because once constitutionally adopted it immediately removes federal jurisdiction; and (2) constitutional amendments do not require presidential approval as they are substantive acts separate from ordinary legislation. This decision established that constitutional amendments can have retroactive effect and clarified the amendment process.

Abstract

The Supreme Court addressed whether the Eleventh Amendment, ratified to overturn a prior decision allowing citizens to sue states in federal court, applies retroactively to pending lawsuits against states. The Court unanimously held that the amendment immediately removes federal jurisdiction in such cases upon adoption, including those already pending. It further clarified that constitutional amendments do not require presidential approval, distinguishing them from ordinary legislation.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
The Courtjoined by Chase, justice
  • The Eleventh Amendment applies retroactively to pending suits
  • Constitutional amendments do not require presidential approval
  • Once adopted, amendments immediately become part of the Constitution and operate to remove jurisdiction

Jurisdiction

challenged
Statutory basis
Article III of the U.S. Constitution
Subject matter
Federal question involving interpretation of the Eleventh Amendment
Jurisdictional holding
The Court lacks jurisdiction because the Eleventh Amendment, once constitutionally adopted, prohibits suits against a state by citizens of another state, including pending cases
Jurisdictional facts
  • The case involves a suit against a state by citizens of another state
  • The Eleventh Amendment was adopted after the suit was instituted

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Suit against a state where defendant never entered an appearance
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal regarding the effect of the Eleventh Amendment on pending suits
Preserved issues
  • Whether the Eleventh Amendment applies retroactively to pending suits
  • Whether the amendment was proposed in the proper constitutional form

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
Hollingsworth, et al. versus Virginia
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Trial court
Not specified
Decided
Opinion author
The Court
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
Chase, justice

Issues & holdings

2
Issues raised
2
affirmed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

The amendment, once constitutionally adopted, operates to deprive the Court of jurisdiction over all suits against states, including those already commenced

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

The President's approval is not required for constitutional amendments, as they are substantive acts unconnected with ordinary legislation

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Retroactive application of the Eleventh Amendment
The Eleventh Amendment applies to all suits against states, including those pending at the time of its adoption
Once constitutionally adopted, the amendment becomes part of the Constitution and operates immediately to remove jurisdiction. The people have the power to amend the Constitution retroactively, and the amendment's language ('commenced or prosecuted') encompasses both past and future suits
unanimousbinding precedent
Procedural validity of the amendment
The Eleventh Amendment was properly proposed without presidential approval
Constitutional amendments are substantive acts unconnected with ordinary legislation and are not subject to the President's veto power under Article I, Section 7
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • The trial court erred in applying the Eleventh Amendment retroactively to pending suits — constitutional · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable
  • The Eleventh Amendment was improperly proposed without presidential approval — procedural · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

2
Statute
Eleventh Amendment to the U.S. Constitution
Question
Whether 'commenced or prosecuted' applies to pending suits
Court's reading
The terms encompass both past and future suits, making the amendment retroactive
Canons applied
Plain meaningAvoidance of absurd results
no legislative history
Statute
Article I, Section 7 of the U.S. Constitution
Question
Whether presidential approval is required for constitutional amendments
Court's reading
Presidential approval is not required for amendments as they are substantive acts separate from ordinary legislation
Canons applied
Textual analysisStructural interpretation
no legislative history

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Not applicable (civil case)
Defence burden
Not applicable
Burden met
false

Standards of review

  • Interpretation of the Eleventh Amendment — de novo The Court reviews constitutional interpretation questions de novo
  • Procedural validity of constitutional amendment — de novo The Court reviews constitutional procedure questions de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Supreme Court decisionAmendment proposedJurisdiction dismissed
3
Events
1,870
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
trial eventcited in opinion

Decision in Chisholm v. Georgia held that states could be sued by citizens of other states in federal court

Outcome: States subject to suit by citizens of other states

Prompted the proposal of the Eleventh Amendment

Jurisdiction over suits against states
Supreme Court supreme court
1794-1795procedural eventcited in opinion

Congress proposed the Eleventh Amendment in response to Chisholm v. Georgia

Outcome: Amendment proposed to states for ratification

Attempt to overturn Chisholm decision

Proper procedure for constitutional amendments
Congress not applicable
appeal eventcited in opinion

Supreme Court delivers unanimous opinion that the Eleventh Amendment deprives the Court of jurisdiction over all suits against states, including pending cases

Outcome: Court dismisses suit for lack of jurisdiction

Established that constitutional amendments apply retroactively unless specified otherwise

Retroactive effect of constitutional amendmentsJurisdiction over states
Supreme Court · W. Tilghman · Rawle · Lee, Attorney General supreme court

Facts & evidence

Key facts

4 facts
  1. The case involves a suit against the state of Virginia by citizens of another state
  2. The Eleventh Amendment was proposed by Congress and adopted by the states after the suit was commenced
  3. The amendment states: 'The Judicial power of the United States shall not be construed to extend to any suit in law and equity, commenced or prosecuted against one of the United States, by citizens of another state, or by citizens or subjects of any foreign state'
  4. The decision in Chisholm v. Georgia (2 Dall. Rep. 419) prompted the amendment

Disputed questions

  • Whether the amendment applies to suits already commenced
  • Whether the amendment was properly proposed without presidential approval

Procedural history

3 steps
  1. Suit was instituted against Virginia
  2. Eleventh Amendment was adopted during the pendency of the suit
  3. Attorney General submitted the question to the Court regarding the amendment's effect on pending suits

Evidence in the record

Documentary
  • The original roll showing the amendment was not submitted to the President
  • The text of the Eleventh Amendment
  • The text of Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution
  • The text of Article V of the Constitution
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Procedural validity of amendment proposal · Challenge basis: Constitutional procedure · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: The Court considered the argument but rejected it · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed

Objects of relevance

Original roll of constitutional amendment proposal

Policy considerations

  • The importance of state sovereignty and immunity from suit
  • The people's power to amend the Constitution retroactively
  • Avoiding the mischief of ex post facto constitutional provisions
  • The distinction between ordinary legislation and constitutional amendments

Authorities

Cited authorities (2)

2 Dall. Rep. 419
distinguishedprecedent
Chisholm v. Georgia decision that prompted the Eleventh Amendment
produced a proposition in Congress, for amending the Constitution
4 Bac. Abr. 636
distinguishedpersuasive
Cited by plaintiffs regarding ex post facto laws and equitable construction
at pi. 5 a statute shall never have an equitable construction, in order to overthrow an estate

Related cases (1)

2 Dall. Rep. 419
prior appeal
States could be sued by citizens of other states in federal court

Statutes

  • Eleventh Amendment to U.S. Constitution
  • Article I, Section 7 of U.S. Constitution
  • Article V of U.S. Constitution

Standards & doctrines

  • De novo review of constitutional interpretation
  • State sovereign immunity doctrine

Legal principles applied

  • Constitutional amendments are substantive acts separate from ordinary legislation
  • The people have power to amend the Constitution retroactively

Notable quotes

“The amendment being constitutionally adopted, there could not be exercised any jurisdiction, in any case, past or future, in which a State was sued by the citizens of another State, or by citizens, or subjects, of any foreign state.”
majority — Court's holding on the retroactive effect of the Eleventh Amendment
Establishes that constitutional amendments apply immediately to all cases, including pending ones
“The negative of the President applies only to the ordinary cases of legislation: He has nothing to do with the proposition, or adoption, of amendments to the Constitution.”
majority — Court's rejection of the argument that presidential approval was required
Clarifies that constitutional amendments are outside the scope of presidential veto power
Index terms72
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
dismissed
Target
suit against Virginia
Appealed from
lower court proceedings
Context
The Court held it could not exercise jurisdiction because the Eleventh Amendment prohibited suits against states by citizens of other states
Scope
full
Further instructions
None
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Chase
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms