Overview
Case summary
Shippen’s Lessee v. Bush involved a motion by attorney Bankson for appointment of referees in a case, claimed to be by agreement with opposing counsel but made in the opposing counsel's absence. The court established two important procedural rules: (1) referees cannot be appointed except in the presence of both parties, and (2) the court will not recognize attorney agreements about referee appointments that are not reduced to writing, due to frequent disputes about the meaning of such agreements. The court affirmed these principles as invariable rules to ensure procedural fairness and clarity.
Abstract
The case involved a motion by an attorney for appointment of referees, claimed to be by agreement with opposing counsel but made in the opposing counsel's absence. The court established invariable procedural rules that referees cannot be appointed except in the presence of both parties and that attorney agreements on such appointments must be reduced to writing to avoid disputes. These principles ensure clarity and fairness in proceedings.
Opinion of the court
opinionBy the Courtjoined by All judges
- Referees cannot be appointed except in presence of both parties
- Court will not recognize unwritten attorney agreements about referee appointments due to disputes about meaning
Procedural posture
- Motion for appointment of referees based on alleged attorney agreement
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Court established invariable rule requiring both parties' presence for referee appointments
Issue preserved for review
de novo
Court determined not to pay regard to agreements not reduced to writing due to disputes about meaning
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Trial court considering motion for referee appointment based on alleged unwritten attorney agreement — procedural · error foundCourt established clear rule to prevent such errors in future · not applicable
Standards of review
- Appointment of referees based on attorney agreements — de novo Legal question about procedural rules for referee appointments
Timeline
Procedural path
Attorney Bankson moved for appointment of referees in Shippen’s Lessee v. Bush
Outcome: Court considered motion
Motion raised issue of whether referees can be appointed based on attorney agreements
Facts & evidence
Key facts
4 facts- Attorney Bankson moved for appointment of referees in the case
- Motion made in absence of opposite counsel
- Bankson claimed motion was by agreement with opposing counsel
- Dispute arose about meaning of attorneys' agreement
Evidence in the record
- Attorney Bankson's claim that motion for referees was by agreement with opposing counsel
Authorities
Standards & doctrines
- Invariable rule for referee appointments
- Requirement of written agreements for attorney procedural agreements
Legal principles applied
- Procedural fairness requires both parties' presence for referee appointments
- Written agreements prevent disputes about attorney intentions