Overview
Case summary
Schenkhouse v. Gibbs et al. (1794) involved a commercial dispute where a factor employed by several distinct foreign merchants remitted funds via a general bill payable to one merchant with separate drafts for each other merchant. The plaintiff challenged this mode of remittance. The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania held that such remittance is lawful if all parties are apprised of the distributive appropriation, with notice being essential but suppliable by facts raising a fair presumption of knowledge. The court found the plaintiff's delay in protesting and the direct sending of a draft provided such notice. Additionally, the court ruled that any partial loss must be borne as a general average by all concerned parties. The verdict for defendants was affirmed.
Abstract
In a commercial dispute, a factor employed by foreign merchants remitted funds via a general bill payable to one merchant with separate drafts for others, which the plaintiff challenged as improper. The court held the remittance lawful if all parties were apprised through notice or facts raising a fair presumption of knowledge, finding such notice established by the plaintiff's delay in protesting and direct sending of a draft. Any partial loss was ruled to be borne as general average by all concerned parties, affirming the verdict for defendants.
Opinion of the court
opinionBy the Court.
- Mode of remittance by factor is lawful with proper notice
- Notice can be implied from circumstances
- Partial loss borne as general average
Jurisdiction
not challengedProcedural posture
- Mode of remittance by a factor
- Notice requirement for remittance
- General average for partial loss
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
The court found this mode lawful if all parties are apprised of the distributive appropriation
Issue preserved for review
de novo
The court held notice is essential but can be supplied by facts raising a fair presumption of knowledge
Issue preserved for review
de novo
The court ruled partial loss must be borne as a general average by all concerned
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Unlawful mode of remittance by factor — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
- Lack of notice to plaintiff — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Lawfulness of remittance mode and notice requirement — de novo Legal questions regarding commercial law principles
Timeline
Procedural path
Trial of the case before a jury with court delivering charge
Outcome: Verdict for defendants
Established legal principles regarding factor remittances and general average
Facts & evidence
Key facts
5 facts- A factor was employed by several distinct and unconnected foreign merchants
- The factor remitted funds via a general bill payable to one merchant with separate drafts for each other merchant
- No express notice of this remittance was given to the plaintiff
- The plaintiff delayed in protesting and returning the bill
- A draft on Portener was sent directly by defendants to the plaintiff
Procedural history
2 steps- Case tried before a jury with a charge delivered by the court
- Verdict rendered for defendants
Evidence in the record
- No proof of express notice to plaintiff
- General bill payable to one merchant
- Separate drafts in favor of each other merchant
- Draft on Portener sent to plaintiff
- Evidence type: Mode of remittance · Challenge basis: Lawfulness of factor's remittance method · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Court found it lawful with proper notice · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
Jury
- Charge delivered by court regarding factor remittance and general average
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Related cases (1)
Statutes
- Commercial law principles regarding factors
Standards & doctrines
- General average doctrine for loss allocation
- Factor's authority doctrine in commercial law
Legal principles applied
- Notice requirement for factor remittances can be supplied by facts raising fair presumption of knowledge
- Partial loss borne as general average by all concerned
Notable quotes
“We are of opinion, that the mode of remitting by a general bill, payable to one merchant, with separate drafts in favor of each of the other merchants, who are interested in the amount of the bill, is a good and lawful execution of the trust and authority of a factor, employed by several distinct and unconnected merchants, resident abroad.”majority — Court's holding on lawfulness of factor remittanceEstablishes legal principle for factor transactions
“It is essential, however, to such a remittance, that notice should be given to the parties.”majority — Court's requirement for notice in factor remittancesEmphasizes notice as crucial element