Ewing v. Houston

Decided Common Pleas
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Supreme Court
Decided
Posture
Judgment of common pleas affirmed by Supreme Court
Plaintiffs in error (plaintiffs in partition)s (2)
Ewing and wife
Lewis
v.
Defendants in errors (2)
Houston and wife
Ingersoll, Hopkins

Overview

Judgment affirmed.

Case summary

This case involves a partition proceeding between tenants in common, Ewing and wife (plaintiffs) and Houston and wife (defendants), over property including a ferry, messuages, and land in York county, Pennsylvania. The plaintiffs initiated partition via a writ of summons describing property in Hellam township. A writ of partition was issued, but it added Windsor township in the recital, omitted the ferry in the mandatory clause, and the inquisition included a fishery not demanded. The sheriff returned the writ as executed without stating parties were warned or that property was assigned and delivered. The plaintiffs appealed, arguing these variances and omissions invalidated the partition. The Supreme Court affirmed the partition judgment, and the Common Pleas court, on writ of error, unanimously affirmed, holding the variances were not fatal, omissions were not material, and objections were waived or too late.

Abstract

In a partition proceeding between tenants in common over property including a ferry, messuages, and land, plaintiffs initiated action via writ of summons, but the writ of partition contained variances in township description, omitted the ferry, and the inquisition added a fishery not demanded, while the sheriff's return lacked required statements. Plaintiffs appealed, arguing these defects invalidated the partition. The court affirmed the judgment, holding the variances and omissions non-fatal and objections waived or untimely.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
joined by Rush, Ridlue, Addison, Henry, Coxe
  • Variances in partition proceedings not fatal if property same
  • Omissions in writ not material if property contemplated throughout
  • Inclusion of appurtenant property acceptable
  • Notice presumed from sheriff's return
  • Allotment sufficient compliance with writ

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Writ of error from Supreme Court
Jurisdictional facts
  • Writ of error brought by plaintiff in partition on judgment of common pleas
  • Judgment affirmed by Supreme Court
  • Cause removed into this court by same party

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Judgment of common pleas affirmed by Supreme Court
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal via writ of error
Preserved issues
  • Variance between writ of summons and writ of partition
  • Omission of ferry in mandatory clause of writ of partition
  • Inclusion of fishery in inquisition
  • Lack of notice to parties
  • Return stating allotment rather than assignment and delivery

Subsequent history

Petition for rehearing
not filed
Rehearing en banc
not filed
Petition for certiorari
not filed

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Full case name
Ewing and wife v. Houston and wife
Court
Common Pleas
Trial court
Supreme Court
Decided
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
RushRidlueAddisonHenryCoxe

Issues & holdings

5
Issues raised
5
affirmed
5
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Variance not fatal; addition of Windsor township disregarded as surplusage or amendment for certainty

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Ferry mentioned in other clauses and contemplated throughout; omission not fatal

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Fishery appurtenant to lot and named as detail; not fatal

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Notice presumed from sheriff's return and plaintiff's issuance of writ; objection too late on writ of error

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Allotment deemed compliance with writ's terms

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Variance in township description
Variance not fatal
Addition of Windsor township disregarded as surplusage or amendment for greater certainty; all proceedings refer to same specific property
unanimousbinding precedent
Omission of ferry in mandatory clause
Omission not fatal
Ferry mentioned in other clauses of writ and contemplated throughout record; may be considered appurtenant to lot
unanimousbinding precedent
Inclusion of fishery in inquisition
Inclusion not fatal
Fishery appurtenant to lot and named as matter of detail and specification
unanimousbinding precedent
Lack of notice to parties
Partition valid despite lack of explicit notice
Notice presumed from sheriff's return and plaintiff's issuance of writ; objection comes too late on writ of error
unanimousbinding precedent
Return stating allotment rather than assignment and delivery
Partition valid
Allotment deemed compliance with writ's terms; sheriff returned obedience to command
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Variance between writ of summons and writ of partition in township description — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
  • Omission of ferry in mandatory clause of writ of partition — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
  • Inclusion of fishery in inquisition not demanded — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
  • Lack of notice to parties for execution of writ — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
  • Return stating allotment rather than assignment and delivery — procedural · no error foundnot applicable

Burden of proof

Standards of review

  • All issues on appeal — de novo Legal issues regarding validity of partition proceedings reviewed de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Writ of summons issuedParties appearedJudgment for partitionWrit of partition issuedPartition made and confirmedCertiorari issuedJudgment affirmed
6
Events
2,694
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
filingcited in opinion

Writ of summons in partition issued by plaintiff in error in court of common pleas of York county, returnable to September term 1792

Outcome: Summons returned

Initiates partition proceeding

Variance between writ of summons and writ of partition
Ewing and wife · Houston and wife York county trial court
trial eventcited in opinion

Parties appeared by attorneys, plaintiffs filed declaration, judgment rendered by consent that partition be made

Outcome: Judgment for partition

Court orders partition

Variance between writ of summons and writ of partition
Ewing and wife · Houston and wife · attorneys York county trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Writ of partition issued on judgment, returnable to December term 1792

Outcome: Writ issued

Execution of partition ordered

Variance between writ of summons and writ of partitionOmission of ferry in mandatory clause
sheriff York county trial court
trial eventcited in opinion

Sheriff returned writ that partition had been made, parties appeared by attorneys, judgment rendered confirming partition

Outcome: Partition confirmed

Partition finalized by court

Lack of notice to partiesReturn stating allotment rather than assignment and delivery
Ewing and wife · Houston and wife · attorneys · sheriff York county trial court
appeal eventcited in opinion

Case heard at July sessions 1799, court mentioned doubts and directed certiorari to issue to common pleas of York county

Outcome: Certiorari issued

Court seeks additional information on precept for writ of execution

Judges Rush, Ridlue, Addison, Henry, Coxe appellate court
appeal eventcited in opinion

At adjourned session, court unanimously affirmed judgment of Supreme Court

Outcome: Judgment affirmed

Appeal decided

All issues on appeal
Judges Rush, Ridlue, Addison, Henry, Coxe appellate court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
Hellam township and Windsor township, York county, Pennsylvania

Key facts

8 facts
  1. Plaintiffs sought partition of property held as tenants in common
  2. Property included ferry at Susquehanna River, six messuages, barn, stables, gardens, orchard, arable land, woodland
  3. Writ of summons described property as in Hellam township
  4. Writ of partition added Windsor township in recital
  5. Writ of partition omitted ferry in mandatory clause but mentioned it elsewhere
  6. Inquisition divided ferry and included fishery not demanded
  7. Sheriff returned writ as executed but did not state parties attended or were warned
  8. Return stated property allotted but not assigned and delivered

Disputed questions

  • Whether variance in township description fatal
  • Whether omission of ferry in mandatory clause invalidates partition
  • Whether inclusion of fishery invalidates partition
  • Whether lack of notice to parties invalidates partition
  • Whether return stating allotment rather than assignment and delivery invalidates partition

Procedural history

7 steps
  1. Writ of summons issued September 1792
  2. Parties appeared, declaration filed, judgment for partition rendered by consent December 1792
  3. Writ of partition issued, returned executed December 1792
  4. Judgment confirming partition rendered
  5. Writ of error brought to Supreme Court
  6. Supreme Court affirmed judgment
  7. Case removed to this court

Evidence in the record

Physical
  • Draft annexed to inquisition showing lots
Documentary
  • Writ of summons
  • Declaration
  • Judgment for partition
  • Writ of partition
  • Inquisition
  • Sheriff's return
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Writ of partition · Challenge basis: Variance from writ of summons · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Variance not fatal · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
  • Evidence type: Inquisition · Challenge basis: Inclusion of fishery not demanded · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Fishery appurtenant · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed

Jury

Sentencing

Sentence challenged on appeal
false

Objects of relevance

Ferry at Susquehanna RiverSix messuagesBarnStablesGardensOrchardArable landWoodlandFishery on Susquehanna River

Policy considerations

  • Presumption in favor of judgments
  • Presumption sheriff acted lawfully
  • Avoidance of technicalities in partition proceedings

Authorities

Cited authorities (5)

1 Inst. 154 a
citedprecedent
Cited by plaintiff regarding execution obtaining possession
2 Hawk. P. C. c. 46, § 34
citedprecedent
Cited by plaintiff regarding necessity to prove named locations
Cro. Eliz. 185, 329, 330, 829
citedprecedent
Cited by plaintiff regarding fatal variance in recital of record
2 Keb. 413
citedprecedent
Cited by defendant regarding intendment in favor of judgment
Moore 692
citedprecedent
Cited by defendant that plaintiffs cannot take advantage of own error

Standards & doctrines

  • De novo review of legal issues
  • Presumption in favor of judgments

Legal principles applied

  • Every intendment made in favor of a judgment
  • Presumption sheriff acted lawfully
  • Technical errors not fatal in partition

Notable quotes

“Held, that these variances were not fatal.”
majority — Court's holding on variances in partition proceedings
Establishes leniency in partition procedural errors
“Judgment affirmed.”
majority — Final disposition of the case
Confirms lower court ruling
Index terms107
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
judgment of Supreme Court
Appealed from
Supreme Court
Context
Court unanimously affirmed the judgment of the supreme court
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Action type
affirmed
Target
partition judgment
Appealed from
common pleas
Context
Judgment affirmed on writ of error regarding partition proceedings
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
AddisonCoxeHenryRidlueRush
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms