Overview
Case summary
Schlosser v. Lesher is a 1790 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case addressing procedural rules for trial continuances. Plaintiff Schlosser moved to continue trial due to the absence of a material witness who had been subpoenaed. Defendant Lesher opposed the continuance and requested a rule for trial next term or non pros (non prosequitur). The plaintiff argued that such rules only apply when there is laches (negligence or delay) by the plaintiff, which was not present here. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in a per curiam opinion, granted the rule for trial or non pros but preserved the plaintiff's right to show reasonable cause of delay at the next term. The court cited precedent (Bowen v. Douglas) and distinguished cases involving plaintiff laches. The decision balances the defendant's interest in timely trial resolution with the plaintiff's right to present their case when a material witness is unavoidably absent.
Abstract
Plaintiff sought a trial continuance due to the absence of a subpoenaed material witness, while defendant opposed it and requested a rule for trial next term or non pros. Plaintiff argued that such rules apply only in cases of plaintiff laches, which was absent here. The court granted the rule but preserved plaintiff's right to show reasonable cause of delay at the next term, balancing timely resolution with the right to present evidence.
Opinion of the court
opinionBy the Courtjoined by By the Court
- Rule for trial or non pros may be entered even without plaintiff laches
- Plaintiff retains right to show reasonable cause of delay at next term
- Distinguishes from cases where rule applies due to plaintiff negligence
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Case involves a motion to continue trial due to absence of material witness
Procedural posture
- Motion to continue trial due to absence of material witness
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
abuse of discretion
Court grants rule but allows plaintiff to show reasonable cause of delay at next term
Issue preserved for review
de novo
Court enters rule but preserves plaintiff's right to show cause, distinguishing from cases where laches exists
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Continuance motion — abuse of discretion Trial court discretion in managing trial schedule and continuance requests
- Application of rule for trial or non pros — de novo Legal interpretation of procedural rules
Timeline
Procedural path
Plaintiff Schlosser moves to continue trial due to absence of material witness who had been subpoenaed
Outcome: Motion considered by court
Sets up procedural dispute over continuance and rules for trial
Defendant Lesher opposes continuance and requests rule for trial next term or non pros
Outcome: Defendant's request opposed by plaintiff
Creates conflict over appropriate procedural rule when no plaintiff laches
Pennsylvania Supreme Court issues per curiam opinion granting rule but allowing plaintiff to show reasonable cause of delay at next term
Outcome: Rule entered but plaintiff may show cause of delay
Establishes procedural rule balancing defendant's interest in timely trial with plaintiff's right to present case
Facts & evidence
Key facts
3 facts- Plaintiff Schlosser sought to continue trial due to absence of material witness who had been subpoenaed
- Defendant Lesher opposed continuance and requested rule for trial next term or non pros
- Dispute over whether rule for trial or non pros should apply when no laches by plaintiff
Procedural history
4 steps- Plaintiff moved to continue trial due to absent witness
- Defendant opposed and requested rule for trial next term or non pros
- Trial court considered motion
- Appeal to Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Evidence in the record
- Affidavit stating want of material witness who had been subpoenaed
Objects of relevance
Policy considerations
- Balancing timely trial resolution with fair opportunity to present case
- Consistency in procedural rules across courts
Authorities
Cited authorities (3)
Related cases (3)
Standards & doctrines
- Abuse of discretion standard for continuance motions
Legal principles applied
- Balancing defendant's interest in timely trial with plaintiff's right to present case
Notable quotes
“Let the rule be entered: but this will not preclude the plaintiff from showing reasonable cause of delay, at the next term.”majority — Court's ruling on motion for continuance and rule for trial or non prosEstablishes balancing test between defendant's rule request and plaintiff's right to show cause