Edgar's Lessee v. Robinson

Decided Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
York County Court
Decided
Judge
By the Court
Defendantss (3)
James Robinson, Jr., and William Robinson
v.
Plaintiff (1)
Edgar’s Lessee
Other parties: James Robinson, senior — Uncle of defendants and former defendant in ejectment, Samuel Edgar — Lessor of the plaintiff

Overview

The court affirmed the trial court's judgment, allowing parol evidence of the deed without notice to produce it, as the defendant was not a party to the deed and could not be compelled to produce it as a mere witness.

Case summary

This 1805 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involved an ejectment action where the plaintiff sought to establish title to one-third of premises through a chain of conveyances, including a sheriff's deed. At trial, parol evidence was offered to show a conveyance to James Robinson, senior, without notice to produce the deed. The defendants objected, but the trial court admitted the evidence, leading to a plaintiff's verdict. On appeal, the court affirmed, holding that parol evidence of a deed is admissible without notice against a non-party to the deed, and such a person cannot be compelled to produce it if merely a witness, as the defendant here was not a party to the deed and the general rule did not apply.

Abstract

In an ejectment action, the plaintiff sought to establish title to a portion of premises through a chain of conveyances including a sheriff's deed, offering parol evidence to prove a conveyance without notice to produce the deed. The defendants objected, but the trial court admitted the evidence, resulting in a verdict for the plaintiff. The appellate court affirmed, holding that parol evidence of a deed is admissible without notice against a non-party to the deed, who cannot be compelled to produce it as a mere witness.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
By the Courtjoined by Chief Justice Tilghman, Judge Yeates
  • Defendant not party to deed, so no notice required for parol evidence
  • Defendant as witness not compellable to produce deed
  • Parol evidence admissible to access title when defendant conceals muniments

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Full case name
Edgar’s Lessee v. James Robinson, Jr., and William Robinson
Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Trial court
York County Court
Trial court judge
Not specified
Decided
Opinion author
By the Court
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
Chief Justice TilghmanJudge Yeates

Issues & holdings

1
Issues raised
1
affirmed
1
Holdings
Standard of review

Not specified

Disposition rationale

Defendant not party to deed, so no notice required; defendant as mere witness not compellable to produce deed

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Admissibility of parol evidence of deed without notice
Parol evidence of a deed is admissible without notice to produce it against one not a party to the deed, and such person cannot be compelled to produce it if merely a witness
Defendant James Robinson, Jr. is not party to alleged deed, so general rule requiring notice does not apply; if he stands as witness, he is not compellable to produce deed, allowing parol evidence as only means to access title when defendant conceals muniments
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Trial court erroneously admitted parol evidence of deed without notice to produce it — evidentiary · no error foundNot applicable as no error found · not applicable

Standards of review

  • Admissibility of parol evidence — abuse of discretion Court reviewed trial court's evidentiary ruling

Timeline

Procedural path

Patent issuedPremises conveyedSheriff's deedLand soldPremises devisedTrial heldParol evidence admittedVerdict obtained
5
Events
25,772
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
factual eventcited in opinion

Patent dated to Thomas Lenton for premises

factual eventcited in opinion

Thomas Lenton conveyed premises to James Rowland

factual eventcited in opinion

Sheriff's deed recited judgment and execution against Matthew Johnston and James Robinson, selling one-third of land to Samuel Edgar

factual eventcited in opinion

Robert Rowland devised premises to sons James, John, and Matthew by will

trial eventcited in opinion

Trial at York Town, court admitted parol evidence of deed without notice to produce it

Outcome: Plaintiff obtained verdict

Court's ruling on admissibility of parol evidence formed basis for appeal

trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
York Town, Pennsylvania

Key facts

6 facts
  1. Ejectment action for one-third part of premises
  2. Plaintiff's title derived from 1734 patent to Thomas Lenton, conveyed to James Rowland in 1741
  3. James Rowland conveyed to Robert Rowland, who devised to sons James, John, and Matthew in 1799
  4. Sheriff's deed dated 1785 recited judgment and execution against Matthew Johnston and James Robinson, selling one-third of land to Samuel Edgar
  5. Parol evidence offered to show James Rowland conveyed one-third to James Robinson, senior
  6. James Robinson, senior was in possession at time of judgment and sale

Disputed questions

  • Whether parol evidence of deed was admissible without notice to produce it

Procedural history

5 steps
  1. Trial at York Town
  2. Defense taken for one-third of premises
  3. Objection to parol evidence without notice to produce deed
  4. Court admitted parol evidence
  5. Plaintiff obtained verdict per court's charge

Evidence in the record

Documentary
  • Patent dated 1734
  • Conveyance from Thomas Lenton to James Rowland dated 1741
  • Sheriff's deed dated 1785
  • Will of Robert Rowland dated 1799
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Parol evidence of deed · Challenge basis: Lack of notice to produce deed · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Defendant not party to deed and not compellable as witness · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed

Objects of relevance

Deed as muniment of estateSheriff's deed document

Authorities

Cited authorities (1)

Little v. Delancey, 5 Binn. 171
distinguishedquoteddistinguished
Cited by Chief Justice Tilghman to critique the report of this case and note it should not be a general rule
at 5 Binn. 171 The report is short, and I am satisfied the reporter was not present at the trial, or the case would have been stated with more clearness and precision

Standards & doctrines

  • General rule for production of deeds
  • Exception for non-parties and witnesses

Legal principles applied

  • Parol evidence admissible when defendant not party to deed and not compellable as witness
  • Access to title through parol evidence when muniments concealed
Index terms75
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
trial court judgment
Appealed from
York County Court
Context
Court affirmed trial court's admission of parol evidence and plaintiff's verdict, holding parol evidence admissible without notice as defendant not party to deed
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
TilghmanYeates
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms