Kirkbride v. Durden

Decided Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Disposition
reversed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (as of Bucks county)
Decided
Judge
McKean, Chief Justice
Posture
Judgment entered in supreme court pursuant to warrant of attorney
Plaintiffs in error (debtors) (1)
Kirkbride et al.
Swift
v.
Defendant in error (creditor) (1)
Durden
Wilooeks

Overview

Let the judgment be reversed. Each party shall pay his own costs as provided by act of assembly.

Case summary

This 1787 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involved a writ of error challenging a judgment entered in the supreme court pursuant to a warrant of attorney. The plaintiffs had executed a bond in 1784 with a warrant authorizing confession of judgment in the court of common pleas of Bucks county or 'any other court.' A judgment was entered in the supreme court as of Bucks county in 1787. The court reversed the judgment on two grounds: (1) the act of 1786 prohibited the supreme court from entertaining suits for debts arising before the act, and the bond predated the act; and (2) after January 2, 1787, the supreme court's original jurisdiction was restricted to Philadelphia county only, making the Bucks county judgment erroneous. The court found it unnecessary to decide whether the warrant authorized confession in the supreme court, suggesting it might be valid under liberal construction principles. The judgment was reversed with each party bearing their own costs.

Abstract

Plaintiffs executed a bond with a warrant authorizing confession of judgment in a specified county court or any other court, leading to a judgment entered in the supreme court. The supreme court reversed the judgment because a prior act prohibited it from entertaining suits on pre-existing debts and its original jurisdiction was thereafter limited to one county. The court declined to resolve whether the warrant permitted confession in the supreme court under liberal construction and ordered each party to bear their own costs.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
McKean, Chief Justicejoined by Unanimous court
  • Act of 1786 prohibits supreme court suits for pre-act debts
  • Supreme court jurisdiction after act restricted to Philadelphia county
  • Judgment entered in Bucks county therefore erroneous
  • Warrant of attorney issue not decided as unnecessary

Jurisdiction

challenged
Statutory basis
Act of 1786 (Pennsylvania statute)
Subject matter
Writ of error to review judgment entered in supreme court
Jurisdictional holding
Supreme court lacked jurisdiction to enter judgment due to act of 1786 restrictions
Jurisdictional facts
  • Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county in September Term 1787
  • Writ of error sued out to set judgment aside

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Judgment entered in supreme court pursuant to warrant of attorney
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal via writ of error
Preserved issues
  • Validity of judgment under act of 1786
  • Jurisdiction of supreme court to enter judgment
Forfeited issues
  • Assignment of errors in fact due to plea in nullo est erratum

Subsequent history

Petition for rehearing
not filed

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
Kirkbride et al., Plaintiffs in error, v. Durden
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Trial court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (as of Bucks county)
Trial court judge
Not specified
Decided
Opinion author
McKean, Chief Justice
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
McKean, Chief Justice

Issues & holdings

3
Issues raised
2
reversed
1
not decided
3
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Act expressly prohibited suits for debts arising before act except specific exceptions not applicable here

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

After 2 January 1787, supreme court original jurisdiction restricted to Philadelphia county only

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Court found it unnecessary to decide given reversal on other grounds

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Jurisdiction under act of 1786 for pre-act debts
Judgment could not be entered in supreme court for debt arising before act of 1786
Act expressly stated 'no suit or action shall be commenced in the said supreme court, for any debt or cause which arose before the passing of this act, except suits of the commonwealth, and such wherein the title of land, or other real estate, may come in question'
unanimousbinding precedent
Jurisdiction for post-act judgments outside Philadelphia
Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county after act restricted jurisdiction to Philadelphia was erroneous
After 2 January 1787, supreme court original jurisdiction restricted to Philadelphia county by section 4 of act; judgment entered in Bucks county violated this restriction
unanimousbinding precedent
Construction of warrant of attorney
Court suggests warrant might authorize confession in supreme court but does not decide
Rule that acts of parties should be liberally construed to promote remedy; long practice supports validity but unnecessary to decide given reversal on jurisdictional grounds
unanimousnon-binding

Error analysis

  • Judgment entered in supreme court for pre-act debt — procedural · error foundNot analyzed as error required reversal · not harmless
  • Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county after jurisdiction restricted to Philadelphia — procedural · error foundNot analyzed as error required reversal · not harmless

Statutory interpretation

2
Statute
Act of 1786 (Pennsylvania)
Question
Whether supreme court could entertain suits for debts arising before act
Court's reading
No, except for commonwealth suits or where title to land is questioned
Canons applied
plain meaningexpressio unius est exclusio alterius
Statute
Act of 1786, section 4
Question
Geographic jurisdiction of supreme court after act
Court's reading
Original jurisdiction restricted to Philadelphia county only after January 2, 1787
Canons applied
plain meaning

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Plaintiff in error must show error in judgment
Burden met
true

Standards of review

  • Statutory interpretation of act of 1786 — de novo Court interprets statute's meaning and application
  • Jurisdictional validity of judgment — de novo Court reviews legal authority to enter judgment

Timeline

Procedural path

Bond executedAct passedJudgment enteredWrit sued
4
Events
608
Days, incident to ruling
— September Term 1787
Span
procedural eventcited in opinion

Act of assembly passed restricting supreme court original jurisdiction to Philadelphia county and prohibiting suits for debts arising before act

Statutory basis for jurisdictional challenge to judgment

Pennsylvania legislature not applicable
appeal eventcited in opinion

Writ of error sued out to set aside judgment, errors assigned including jurisdiction and warrant validity

Outcome: Supreme court hears appeal

Brings case before appellate court for review

Kirkbride et al. · Durden · Supreme court appellate court
23 October 1784factual eventcited in opinion

Plaintiffs executed bond to defendant with warrant of attorney to confess judgment and mortgage of lands in Bucks county

Created debt and security interest underlying the judgment

Kirkbride et al. · Durden
September Term 1787procedural eventcited in opinion

Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county pursuant to warrant of attorney

Outcome: Judgment entered against plaintiffs

Action being challenged on writ of error

Supreme court trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date
23 October 1784

Key facts

4 facts
  1. Plaintiffs executed bond to defendant dated 23 October 1784 with warrant to confess judgment
  2. Warrant directed to attorney of court of common pleas of Bucks county or any other attorney of any other court
  3. Simultaneous mortgage of lands in Bucks county as collateral security
  4. Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county in September Term 1787

Disputed questions

  • Whether warrant authorized confession in supreme court
  • Whether supreme court had jurisdiction under act of 1786

Procedural history

4 steps
  1. Judgment entered in supreme court
  2. Writ of error sued out to set aside judgment
  3. Errors assigned including jurisdiction and warrant validity
  4. Plea in nullo est erratum filed

Evidence in the record

Documentary
  • Bond dated 23 October 1784
  • Warrant of attorney
  • Mortgage of lands in Bucks county
  • Act of 1786 statute
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Judgment entered in supreme court · Challenge basis: Jurisdictional authority under act of 1786 · Trial court ruling: admitted · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: reversed

Objects of relevance

Mortgage of lands in Bucks county as collateral security

Policy considerations

  • Avoiding uncertainty and litigation in early interpretation of new statute
  • Preventing conflicting judgment liens across different counties
  • Facilitating transfer of lands by clear title
  • Promoting remedy through liberal construction of private instruments

Authorities

Cited authorities (7)

1 State Laws, 273, § 7
appliedprecedent
Cited for rule that on reversal of judgment, each party pays own costs
2 Bac. Abr. 218
citedpersuasive
Cited by Swift regarding pleading rules for errors in fact vs. law
2 Co. 46
citedpersuasive
Cited by Swift for rule that where inferior thing mentioned, superior cannot be intended
2 Inst. 457-8
citedpersuasive
Cited by Swift for uniform judicial determinations on warrant construction
Wright v. Small, 5 Binn. 204
followedprecedent
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants through long practice
Landis v. Shaffer, 4 S. & R. 199
followedprecedent
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants through long practice
Work v. Maclay, 14 Id. 265
followedprecedent
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants through long practice

Related cases (5)

Wright v. Small, 5 Binn. 204
prior appeal
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants
Landis v. Shaffer, 4 S. & R. 199
prior appeal
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants
Work v. Maclay, 14 Id. 265
prior appeal
Cited as supporting validity of judgments under similar warrants
Sliver v. Shelback, ante, p. 165
companion case
Same point
Moore v. McEwen, 5 S. & R. 373
companion case
Same point

Statutes

  • Act of 1786 (Pennsylvania) restricting supreme court jurisdiction

Standards & doctrines

  • Liberal construction of private instruments to promote remedy
  • Statutory restriction of court jurisdiction

Legal principles applied

  • Acts of parties shall be liberally construed to promote remedy
  • Statutory restrictions on jurisdiction must be followed

Notable quotes

“We are happy that this cause has come before us, so recently after the passing of the act of assembly ; as, by an early settlement of the practice, much uncertainty and litigation may be avoided.”
McKean, Chief Justice — Opening of opinion discussing importance of early interpretation of new statute
Shows court's intent to establish clear precedent under new law
“The intention of the legislature was, evidently, to prohibit the entering up judgments on bonds, &c., by virtue of warrants of attorney in that court, which should affect the lands of the party in any other county than Philadelphia”
McKean, Chief Justice — Explaining policy behind jurisdictional restriction
Court interprets legislative purpose to avoid conflicting liens across counties
“it is a rule, that the acts of the parties, as well as the acts of parliament, shall be liberally construed to promote the remedy”
McKean, Chief Justice — Discussing construction of warrant of attorney
States principle of liberal construction for private instruments
Index terms63
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
reversed
Target
Judgment entered in supreme court as of Bucks county
Appealed from
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Context
Court reverses judgment on two grounds: (1) debt arose before act of 1786 which prohibited such suits, and (2) supreme court jurisdiction after act restricted to Philadelphia county only
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Mckean
Courts
Practice areas
Other index terms