Overview
Case summary
This 1788 Pennsylvania case involves an appeal from a Justice of the Peace decision. Loyer, an insolvent debtor, deposited an Atlas with plaintiff Boinod to sell. Defendant Pelosi purchased the Atlas at Boinod's store, then refused to pay upon discovering it belonged to Loyer, claiming a right to set-off his debt against the price. The Justice of the Peace refused the set-off, and defendant appealed. At trial, defendant argued the set-off should be allowed under insolvent law and that the action could not be maintained in Boinod's name as only assignees could sue for insolvent's effects. The court held plaintiff had indisputable right to bring action in his own name as contract was made with him, and that no set-off existed at common law or by legislative provision for a factor. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff.
Abstract
An insolvent debtor deposited goods with a factor for sale, who sold them to the defendant, who then refused payment upon discovery of the debtor's insolvency and claimed a set-off against his debt. The trial court rejected the set-off, affirming the factor's right to sue in his own name on the contract made with him, as no set-off was available at common law or by statute for factors. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff, upholding the factor's claim.
Opinion of the court
opinionSHIPPEN, President
- Plaintiff had right to bring action in own name as contract made with him
- No set-off at common law or by legislative provision for factor
- Plaintiff entitled to recover though answerable over to assignees
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Defendant appealed from Justice of the Peace decision refusing set-off
Procedural posture
- Right to bring action in plaintiff's name
- Set-off under insolvent law
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Plaintiff had indisputable right to bring action in his own name as contract was made with him
Issue preserved for review
de novo
No set-off at common law and not authorized by legislative provision for factor
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Justice of the Peace refusal to admit set-off — procedural · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable
- Action maintained in Boinod's name rather than assignees' name — procedural · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable
Statutory interpretation
1Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Right to bring action in plaintiff's name — de novo Legal issue of who may properly bring action
- Set-off under insolvent law — de novo Interpretation of legal rights under insolvent law
Timeline
Procedural path
Trial of appeal from Justice of the Peace decision
Outcome: Verdict for plaintiff
Court upheld plaintiff's right to sue in own name and rejected defendant's set-off claim
Facts & evidence
Key facts
6 facts- Loyer, an insolvent debtor, deposited an Atlas with plaintiff Boinod to sell
- Defendant Pelosi purchased the Atlas at Boinod's store
- Pelosi discovered Atlas belonged to Loyer and refused to pay, claiming right to set-off his debt against price
- Plaintiff summoned defendant before Justice of the Peace
- Justice refused to admit set-off
- Defendant appealed from Justice's decision
Procedural history
4 steps- Plaintiff brought action before Justice of the Peace
- Justice refused defendant's set-off claim
- Defendant appealed to higher court
- Trial of appeal conducted with jury
Evidence in the record
- Atlas deposited with plaintiff for sale
- Insolvent law provisions referenced
- Evidence type: Set-off claim · Challenge basis: Common law and legislative authority · Trial court ruling: excluded · Reasoning: No set-off at common law and not authorized by legislative provision for factor · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
Jury
- Action for goods sold and delivered
- Plaintiff had indisputable right to bring action either in own name or name of principal
- Properly chose former as contract made with him
- In answer to defendant's allegation of property belonging to Loyer, property was for benefit of all Loyer's creditors
- Factor might have lien but vendee of factor certainly had none
- Assignees of Loyer had right to Atlas or price, but at time of sale not property of Loyer
- If not vested in assignees, belonged to Boinod by virtue of special lien
- Plaintiff entitled to recover though answerable over to assignees
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (2)
Statutes
- Insolvent law provisions on set-off
Standards & doctrines
- Factor's right to sue in own name
- Common law rule against set-off
Legal principles applied
- Factor has right to bring action in own name when contract made with him
- No set-off at common law for factor transactions
- Assignees have claim to insolvent's property but factor may have superior lien