Overview
Case summary
This case addresses the proper security for payment of distributive shares of an intestate's estate. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, through Chief Justice McKean, held that orphans' courts should require recognizances rather than bonds from heirs-at-law who take intestate lands at valuation, as recognizances create a lien on the lands themselves, unlike bonds which are merely personal security. The opinion discusses the evolution of this practice, citing subsequent cases that clarified the extent of the lien, ultimately restricting it to the particular lands taken by the heir at valuation.
Abstract
The court held that orphans' courts must require recognizances, not bonds, from heirs-at-law who take intestate lands at valuation, as recognizances create a lien on the lands themselves while bonds provide only personal security. The practice of taking bonds for distributive shares was declared illegal and improper. This ruling applies prospectively.
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
No issues recorded for this case.
Timeline
No timeline recorded.
Facts & evidence
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (14)
Statutes
- Act of assembly entitling individuals to distributive share of estate
Standards & doctrines
- Customary lien doctrine for recognizances in distributive shares
Legal principles applied
- Recognizances in orphans' court are in the nature of a judgment
- Custom restricts lien of recognizances to particular lands taken by heir