Walton v. Willis

Decided Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Orphans' Court
Decided
Judge
Chief Justice McKean

Overview

The court declared the practice of taking bonds for distributive shares illegal and improper, directing orphans' courts to take recognizances instead, creating a lien on the lands. The opinion notes that this ruling would apply prospectively, not retrospectively.

Case summary

This case addresses the proper security for payment of distributive shares of an intestate's estate. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, through Chief Justice McKean, held that orphans' courts should require recognizances rather than bonds from heirs-at-law who take intestate lands at valuation, as recognizances create a lien on the lands themselves, unlike bonds which are merely personal security. The opinion discusses the evolution of this practice, citing subsequent cases that clarified the extent of the lien, ultimately restricting it to the particular lands taken by the heir at valuation.

Abstract

The court held that orphans' courts must require recognizances, not bonds, from heirs-at-law who take intestate lands at valuation, as recognizances create a lien on the lands themselves while bonds provide only personal security. The practice of taking bonds for distributive shares was declared illegal and improper. This ruling applies prospectively.

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Trial court
Orphans' Court
Decided
Opinion author
Chief Justice McKean
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
Chief Justice McKean

Issues & holdings

No issues recorded for this case.

Timeline

No timeline recorded.

Facts & evidence

Objects of relevance

Intestate lands taken at valuation by heir-at-law

Authorities

Cited authorities (14)

Beatty v. Smith, 4 Yeates 102
followedquotedprecedent
Recognisance in orphans' court is in the nature of a judgment
refused to admit evidence of circumstances previous to recognisance
Taggart v. Cooper, 1 S. & R. 497
distinguishedprecedent
Question of extent of lien from recognisance
C. J. Tilghman declined giving an opinion upon the point
Kean v. Franklin, 5 S. & R. 155
followedquotedprecedent
Recognisance as lien and binding on lands even with purchaser without notice
recognisances have been generally understood to be a lien
Allen v. Reesor, 16 S. & R. 10
followedprecedent
Final decision that recognisance bound only lands taken at valuation
held that recognisance bound only the lands of intestate taken at valuation
Hubley v. Hamilton, 1 Yeates 392
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Davis v. Houston, 2 Yeates 289
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Yohe v. Barnet, 1 Binn. 358
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Reigart v. Ellmaker, 6 S. & R. 44
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Kean v. Ellmaker, 7 S. & R. 1
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Smith v. Scudder, 11 S. & R. 325
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Shaupe v. Shaupe, 12 S. & R. 9
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Reigart v. Ellmaker, 14 S. & R. 121
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Franks v. Groff, 14 S. & R. 181
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares
Kean v. Ridgway, 16 S. & R. 60
citedpersuasive
Subject of security for distributive shares

Statutes

  • Act of assembly entitling individuals to distributive share of estate

Standards & doctrines

  • Customary lien doctrine for recognizances in distributive shares

Legal principles applied

  • Recognizances in orphans' court are in the nature of a judgment
  • Custom restricts lien of recognizances to particular lands taken by heir
Index terms47
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
Practice of requiring recognizances for distributive shares
Appealed from
Orphans' Court practice
Context
The court declared the practice of taking bonds illegal and improper, directing orphans' courts to take recognizances instead, creating a lien on the lands.
Scope
full
Further instructions
For the future, expect conformity to this opinion; no retrospect on past cases.
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
GibsonMckeanTilghman
Courts
Locations