Concklin v. The Harmony

3,089
Decided District Court, D. New York
Disposition
decree
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
District Court, D. New York
Decided
Judge
THE COURT
Posture
Libel for salvage filed in admiralty
Libellants (salvors)s (4)
Richard Conklin, Strong Conklin, Enoch Concklin, Nathan Smith
M'-Kinnin, Proctor for Libellants
v.
Respondent (vessel and cargo)s (5)
The Brigantine Harmony, her Tackle, Apparel, Furniture and Cargo
Other parties: Thomas Sheafe — Petitioner for remission of foreign duties, collector of the district of the city of New York — Recipient of duties, Isaac Moses — Auctioneer and surety, Nicholas Low — Surety, Captain Stein — Commander of sloop General Green, provided assistance

Overview

The court decreed that from the proceeds of $56,523.38, costs and duties be paid, and one moiety of the residue be paid as salvage to the libellants in specified shares, with the other moiety retained for claimants.

Case summary

In 1797, the libellants (Richard Conklin, Strong Conklin, Enoch Concklin, and Nathan Smith), owners and crew of the sloop Betsey, discovered the brigantine Harmony abandoned and in distress on the Bahama bank. They undertook a salvage operation involving great labor and danger: jettisoning their own cargo, transferring part of Harmony's cargo, pumping water, and with assistance from another vessel, refloating Harmony and navigating it to New York. They filed a libel in admiralty in the District Court of New York seeking salvage compensation. The court ordered the sale of Harmony and its cargo, and decreed that one moiety (half) of the net proceeds be awarded as salvage, distributed among the libellants based on their roles and services, including compensation for a negro boy Charles. The other moiety was reserved for claimants to the vessel and cargo.

Abstract

Owners and crew of a sloop discovered an abandoned brigantine in distress, performed a dangerous salvage operation by jettisoning their cargo, transferring and pumping the brigantine's cargo, and refloating it with assistance to navigate to port. They filed a libel in admiralty seeking salvage compensation, leading the court to order sale of the vessel and cargo. The court awarded one half of the net proceeds as salvage to the salvors based on their roles, reserving the other half for claimants.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
THE COURT
  • Salvage awarded due to great labor and danger
  • Distribution based on roles and services
  • Costs and duties deducted first

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
admiralty
Jurisdictional facts
  • Libel filed in District Court of New York
  • Case involves salvage of vessel and cargo in navigable waters

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Libel for salvage filed in admiralty
Posture on appeal
Not applicable (trial court decree)
Preserved issues
  • Claim for salvage compensation
  • Distribution of proceeds

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
CONCKLIN et al. v. The HARMONY.
Docket number
3,089
Court
District Court, D. New York
Trial court
District Court, D. New York
Trial court judge
Robert Troup
Decided
Opinion author
THE COURT
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
THE COURT

Issues & holdings

Holdings of the court

Salvage compensation
One moiety (half) of the net proceeds from sale of vessel and cargo allowed as salvage to libellants
Based on great labor, difficulty, and danger in saving abandoned vessel and cargo
unanimousbinding precedent
Distribution of salvage
Salvage moiety distributed among libellants: Richard Conklin (owner/master) gets 4.5 shares, Strong Concklin (owner/mate) 3 shares, Enoch Concklin (mariner/master) 3 shares, Nathan Smith (mariner) 2.5 shares, with additional share for negro boy Charles
Proportional to roles and services in salvage operation
unanimousbinding precedent

Timeline

Procedural path

Vessel abandonedAnchor near vesselJettison cargoTransfer cargoPump vesselVessel refloatedMake sailAnchor againExternal assistanceSail to portArrival at portLibel filedDecree issued
9
Events
157
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
filingcited in opinion

Libel filed in District Court of New York by proctor M'-Kinnin

Outcome: Libel accepted

Initiates legal proceedings

M'-Kinnin · Judge Robert Troup District Court, D. New York trial court
rulingcited in opinion

Court issues decree ordering sale of vessel and cargo, payment of costs and duties, and distribution of salvage

Outcome: Decree issued

Final disposition of case

THE COURT District Court, D. New York trial court
factual eventcited in opinion

Libellants discover brigantine Harmony abandoned and in distress on Bahama bank

Initiates salvage operation

Richard Conklin · Strong Conklin · Enoch Concklin · Nathan Smith Bahama straits not applicable
1797-05-20 to 1797-05-23factual eventcited in opinion

Libellants anchor near Harmony, jettison own cargo from sloop Betsey, transfer part of Harmony's cargo, pump vessel

Efforts to refloat vessel

Richard Conklin · Strong Conklin · Enoch Concklin · Nathan Smith Bahama bank not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Harmony becomes buoyant, libellants heave on cable to bring head around, jettison more cargo to float vessel

Vessel refloated

Richard Conklin · Strong Conklin · Enoch Concklin · Nathan Smith Bahama bank not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Libellants make sail on Harmony despite squally weather and water in hold, forced to anchor again due to current

Continued salvage efforts amid danger

Richard Conklin · Strong Conklin · Enoch Concklin · Nathan Smith Bahama bank not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Sloop General Green under Captain Stein assists in stowing/trimming cargo and pumping for payment of 23 boxes sugar

External assistance secured

Captain Stein · Richard Conklin Bahama bank not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Enoch Concklin, Strong Concklin, and two mariners from General Green (paid $200) take charge of Harmony and sail for New York

Navigation to port

Enoch Concklin · Strong Concklin · two mariners · Richard Conklin Bahama bank to New York not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Harmony and sloop Betsey arrive at port of New York with saved cargo

Salvage completed

Libellants New York not applicable

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date
May 20, 1797
Location
Bahama straits, on Bahama bank near northwest point of Bahama island

Key facts

6 facts
  1. Brigantine Harmony found abandoned on shore, heeled over with sails flying
  2. Libellants discovered vessel in distress, boarded it, found cargo of sugar and molasses with 6.5 feet water in hold
  3. Libellants exerted great labor, danger to save vessel and cargo: jettisoned own cargo, transferred part of Harmony's cargo, pumped water
  4. With assistance from sloop General Green (for payment of 23 boxes sugar), vessel was refloated and navigated to New York
  5. Vessel and saved cargo arrived New York June 7, 1797
  6. Libellants entered vessel at custom-house, posted bond for duties

Disputed questions

  • None explicitly noted in decree

Procedural history

3 steps
  1. Libel filed in District Court of New York
  2. Court ordered sale of vessel and cargo
  3. Decree issued allocating proceeds

Evidence in the record

Direct
  • Libel describing salvage events
  • Decree allocating proceeds
Physical
  • Brigantine Harmony and cargo
  • Sloop Betsey
Testimonial
  • Libellants' account in libel
Documentary
  • Custom-house entry documents
  • Bond for duties

Objects of relevance

Brigantine Harmonysloop Betseycargo of sugar and molassespine-apples and yams

Policy considerations

  • Encouragement of salvage operations to save property at sea

Authorities

Cited authorities (6)

1 Pet. Adm. 34, note
citedprecedent
Case citation in reporter
The Waterloo, Case No. 17,257
citedprecedent
Cited as precedent for salvage
The Henry Ewbank, Id. 6,376
citedprecedent
Cited as precedent for salvage
The Massasoit, Id. 9,260
citedprecedent
Cited as precedent for salvage
Evans v. The Charles, Id. 4,556
citedprecedent
Cited as precedent for salvage
Sewell v. Nine Bales of Cotton, Id. 12,683
citedprecedent
Cited as precedent for salvage

Related cases (5)

The Waterloo, Case No. 17,257
cited
Cited as precedent
The Henry Ewbank, Id. 6,376
cited
Cited as precedent
The Massasoit, Id. 9,260
cited
Cited as precedent
Evans v. The Charles, Id. 4,556
cited
Cited as precedent
Sewell v. Nine Bales of Cotton, Id. 12,683
cited
Cited as precedent

Standards & doctrines

  • Admiralty salvage doctrine

Legal principles applied

  • Salvage rewarded based on labor, difficulty, and danger

Notable quotes

“as a compensation for the saving of the said brigantine and her cargo, it is further ordered, sentenced and decreed by the court, that the clerk pay one moiety of the residue of the sum so as aforesaid brought into court”
majority — Decree awarding salvage
Establishes salvage compensation principle
Index terms94
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
decree
Target
sale and distribution of proceeds from brigantine Harmony and cargo
Appealed from
Libel filed in District Court
Context
Court orders payment of costs, duties, and salvage from proceeds of $56,523.38
Scope
full
Further instructions
Clerk to pay salvage in specified shares, retain other moiety for claimants
Disposition vote
unanimous
Physical materials
Search facets
Parties
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms