Campbell v. The Alknomac

2,350
Decided District Court, D. South Carolina
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Decided
Judge
BEE, District Judge
Posture
Suit in admiralty brought by freighters against the ship for damages
Freighters/Plaintiffss (3)
Campbell, Harvey and Co.
v.
Ship Owner/Defendant (1)
The ALKNOMAC (owned by Mr. Wood)
Other parties: Mr. Wood — Owner of the ship, Wheelwright — Master of the ship, Anderson and Child — Agents for the owner, Mr. Dana — Agent at Norfolk

Overview

The court decreed that the ship be sold, and from the proceeds, the freighters receive the sum of £500 (the charter-party penalty) together with all expenses incurred at Norfolk by the unloading and detention of the vessel, beyond what they are bound to pay in general average. A statement of the amount was to be made by the register and enrolled with the decree.

Case summary

This admiralty case involves a dispute between freighters (Campbell, Harvey and Co.) and the owner of the ship ALKNOMAC (Mr. Wood) arising from a charter-party for a voyage from Liverpool to Charleston via Greenock. After the ship was captured by a French privateer, recaptured by a British warship, and forced into Norfolk due to bad weather, cargo was damaged, plundered, or missing, and repairs were needed. The freighters sued for repayment of repairs and cargo deficiency, alleging barratry by the master and crew. The District Court held that the owner's liability for barratry is limited to the £500 penalty specified in the charter-party, that repairs due to weather are subject to general average contribution, and that expenses from necessary deviation must be shared between vessel and cargo. The court ordered the ship sold, with proceeds to pay the penalty and excess expenses.

Abstract

Dispute arose between freighters and ship owner under a voyage charter-party after the vessel was captured by a privateer, recaptured, and diverted due to weather, resulting in cargo damage, plundering, missing goods, and repair needs. Freighters sued for repair repayment and cargo deficiency, alleging barratry by master and crew. Court limited owner's barratry liability to the charter-party's £500 penalty, deemed weather repairs subject to general average contribution, required shared deviation expenses, and ordered ship sale with proceeds paying the penalty and excess Norfolk expenses beyond general average obligations.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
BEE, District Judge
  • Charter-party penalty limits liability for barratry
  • Owner not liable for repairs unless warranted to keep vessel staunch
  • General average applies to necessary deviation expenses
  • Evidence of barratry by master and crew but recovery capped by contract

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Admiralty
Jurisdictional facts
  • Case involves a charter-party dispute, capture and recapture of a vessel, and issues of barratry and general average in maritime law

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Suit in admiralty brought by freighters against the ship for damages
Posture on appeal
Not applicable (district court decision)
Preserved issues
  • Liability for barratry of master and crew
  • Liability for repairs to vessel
  • General average contributions for deviation expenses

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
CAMPBELL v. The ALKNOMAC
Docket number
2,350
Court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Trial court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Trial court judge
BEE, District Judge
Decided
Opinion author
BEE, District Judge
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
BEE, District Judge

Issues & holdings

Holdings of the court

Liability for barratry of master and crew
Owner of vessel not liable for barratry beyond the sum mentioned in the charter-party
Parties fixed their own damages in charter-party with £500 penalty; court cannot exceed this amount despite strong evidence of barratry
unanimousbinding precedent
Liability for repairs to vessel
Owner not liable for repairs unless warranted by owner to keep vessel staunch during voyage
Charter-party required owner to keep vessel tight, staunch, and strong; but repairs due to tempestuous weather are matter for general average
unanimousbinding precedent
General average for deviation expenses
In case of loss and expense by necessary deviation, both vessel and cargo must contribute in general average
Necessary deviation to Norfolk due to bad weather requires sharing of expenses between ship and cargo owners
unanimousbinding precedent

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Preponderance of evidence (admiralty standard)
Burden met
true

Timeline

Procedural path

Charter-party executedShip sailed GreenockShip captured recapturedShip sailed CorkShip put into NorfolkSurveys cargo landedCaptain mates leftNew crew to CharlestonSuit filedCourt decree sale
10
Events
664
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
filingcited in opinion

Charter-party executed in Liverpool between Anderson and Child (agents for owner) and Wheelwright (master) on behalf of owner Mr. Wood, and Campbell, Harvey and Co. (freighters)

Outcome: Agreement for voyage with stipulated freights and £500 penalty for non-performance

Established contractual relationship and liability limits

Liability for barratryCharter-party penalty limitation
Anderson and Child · Wheelwright · Campbell, Harvey and Co. Liverpool not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Ship sailed from Greenock for Charleston with full load of goods

Beginning of voyage where losses occurred

BarratryGeneral average
Wheelwright · Crew Greenock not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Ship captured by French privateer, then recaptured by British sloop of war and sent to Cork

Outcome: Salvage paid by freighters' agents

Double capture led to claims of cargo deficiency

Cargo deficiencyBarratry
French privateer · British sloop of war Atlantic Ocean, then Cork not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Ship sailed again from Cork for Charleston

Continuation of voyage after salvage

DeviationGeneral average
Wheelwright · Crew Cork not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Ship forced by bad weather and contrary winds to put into Norfolk in distress

Outcome: Crew except mates left ship; captain hired Mr. Dana as agent

Necessary deviation leading to repairs and cargo issues

RepairsGeneral averageBarratry
Wheelwright · Crew Norfolk, Virginia not applicable
procedural eventcited in opinion

Three surveys made at Norfolk; cargo landed for repairs; some cargo found damaged, plundered, or missing

Outcome: Agent sold damaged cargo and reimbursed repairs

Basis for suit over deficiency and repairs

Cargo deficiencyRepairsBarratry
Mr. Dana · Surveyors Norfolk not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Captain and both mates left Norfolk, following crew; agent hired new captain and crew

Outcome: New crew brought ship to Charleston in February 1798

Evidence of barratry and abandonment

Barratry
Wheelwright · Mates · Mr. Dana Norfolk not applicable
filingcited in opinion

Suit brought by Campbell, Harvey and Co. against the ship ALKNOMAC for repayment of repairs and deficiency of goods

Outcome: Decree for sale of ship and payment to freighters

Legal action to recover losses

Liability for barratryCharter-party penaltyGeneral average
Campbell, Harvey and Co. · The ALKNOMAC District Court, D. South Carolina trial court
factual eventcited in opinion

Ship arrived in Charleston with new captain and crew

Completion of voyage after incidents

Damages calculation
New captain · New crew Charleston not applicable
rulingcited in opinion

District Court decree by Judge Bee: ship sold, proceeds to pay freighters £500 penalty plus expenses at Norfolk beyond general average

Outcome: Order for sale and payment

Final disposition limiting liability to charter-party penalty

Liability for barratryCharter-party penaltyGeneral average
BEE, District Judge District Court, D. South Carolina trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date
Location
Atlantic Ocean en route from Greenock to Charleston

Key facts

7 facts
  1. Ship ALKNOMAC chartered on January 30, 1797, in Liverpool by Campbell, Harvey and Co. for voyage from Liverpool to Greenock, then to Charleston, then to Europe
  2. Ship captured by French privateer after two-thirds of voyage to Charleston, then recaptured by British sloop of war and sent to Cork
  3. Agents paid salvage at Cork; ship sailed again for Charleston but forced by bad weather to put into Norfolk in distress in November 1797
  4. Crew except mates left ship at Norfolk; captain in bad health hired Mr. Dana as agent
  5. Three surveys conducted; cargo landed for repairs; some cargo damaged, plundered, or missing
  6. Captain and mates left Norfolk; new captain and crew hired to bring ship to Charleston in February 1798
  7. Agent sold damaged cargo, reimbursed himself for repairs, and freighters sued for repayment and deficiency of goods

Disputed questions

  • Whether deficiency in cargo due to capture or barratry
  • Whether owner liable for barratry beyond charter-party penalty
  • Whether repairs at Norfolk should be general average

Procedural history

5 steps
  1. Charter-party executed January 30, 1797
  2. Vessel captured and recaptured May 1797
  3. Ship put into Norfolk November 1797
  4. Suit brought in district court for damages
  5. District court decree ordering sale of ship and payment to freighters

Evidence in the record

Direct
  • Charter-party document specifying terms and £500 penalty
  • Captain's protest at Cork mentioning porter drunk by French
  • Confession by captain that he sold three boxes at Cork for £180
  • Decree of district court in Virginia restoring seized goods to agent
Physical
  • Damaged cargo sold at auction
Testimonial
  • Reports from surveys at Norfolk
  • Agent Mr. Dana's actions and accounts
Documentary
  • Manifest signed by captain
  • Bills of lading
  • Custom-house officer's report
Circumstantial
  • Deficiency of 36 boxes, trunks, etc., worth £3500 sterling, shown by comparison of manifest with survey report
  • Goods found on seamen at Norfolk
  • Bundles and boxes broken open and robbed when vessel boarded at Norfolk
  • All seamen left ship at Norfolk, followed by captain and mates
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Deficiency in cargo · Challenge basis: Attributed to double capture rather than barratry · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Court found barratry more likely given circumstances · Challenged on appeal: false

Objects of relevance

Ship ALKNOMAC (vessel subject to charter and sale)Cargo including boxes, trunks, and bundles

Policy considerations

  • Contractual freedom in maritime agreements
  • Fair allocation of risk in shipping ventures

Authorities

Cited authorities (6)

Arthur v. The Cassius, Case No. 564
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues
Donahoe v. Ivettell, Case No. 3,980
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues
The Casco, Case No. 2,486
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues
The Star of Hope, 9 Wall. (76 U. S.) 203
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues
The Joseph Farwell, 31 Fed. 844
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues
Potter v. Ocean Ins. Co., Case No. 11,335
citedcompanion case
Cited as related admiralty case on similar issues

Related cases (6)

Arthur v. The Cassius, Case No. 564
companion case
Donahoe v. Ivettell, Case No. 3,980
companion case
The Casco, Case No. 2,486
companion case
The Star of Hope, 9 Wall. (76 U. S.) 203
companion case
The Joseph Farwell, 31 Fed. 844
companion case
Potter v. Ocean Ins. Co., Case No. 11,335
companion case

Statutes

  • Trade laws of the United States (referenced for forfeiture)

Standards & doctrines

  • General average doctrine for maritime losses

Legal principles applied

  • Parties may fix damages by contract in maritime law
  • Necessary deviation requires general average contribution

Notable quotes

“But the parties have thereby fixed their own damages, and I cannot exceed them.”
majority — Regarding the charter-party penalty limiting liability for barratry
Emphasizes contractual limitation on damages despite evidence of wrongdoing
“In case of loss and expense by necessary deviation, both vessel and cargo must contribute in general average.”
majority — Holding on general average for deviation expenses
States principle of shared liability for maritime emergencies
Index terms87
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
Charter-party penalty limitation
Appealed from
Not applicable
Context
Court upheld that owner's liability for barratry is limited to £500 penalty in charter-party
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Action type
reversed
Target
Claim for full liability for barratry
Appealed from
Freighters' argument for full recovery
Context
Court rejected freighters' claim for full value of cargo deficiency due to barratry, limiting to contract penalty
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Action type
remanded
Target
Calculation of general average expenses
Appealed from
Not applicable
Context
Court ordered statement of amount for expenses at Norfolk beyond general average to be made by register
Scope
further proceedings
Further instructions
Register to make statement and enroll with decree
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Bee
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms