Overview
Case summary
This 1789 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involves a challenge to a foreign attachment writ issued against defendant Foreman. The plaintiff Lyle, as administrator, sought to attach Foreman's property through foreign attachment. Evidence showed Foreman was in Lancaster, Pennsylvania on December 5, 1789, intending to travel to Fort Pitt and then to a Spanish settlement on the Mississippi, but he was actually at Fort Pitt on January 2, 1790. The court held that while a person remains in Pennsylvania, even if declaring an intention to leave, they must be considered an inhabitant and therefore not subject to foreign attachment. Foreign attachment is only available against non-inhabitants who have notoriously emigrated and settled elsewhere. Since Foreman was still an inhabitant when the writ issued, the foreign attachment could not be maintained. The court made absolute the rule to quash the writ.
Abstract
Plaintiff sought to attach defendant's property via foreign attachment writ, but evidence showed defendant was still physically present in Pennsylvania despite intentions to leave. The court ruled that a person remaining in the state, even with declared plans to depart, qualifies as an inhabitant not subject to foreign attachment, which applies only to non-inhabitants who have notoriously emigrated and settled elsewhere. The rule to quash the writ was made absolute, preventing maintenance of the foreign attachment.
Opinion of the court
opinionShippen, Presidentjoined by Shippen, President
- Person remaining in state is inhabitant regardless of stated intention to leave
- Foreign attachment unavailable against inhabitants
- Only domestic attachment applies to inhabitants
- Foreign attachment requires notorious emigration and settlement elsewhere
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Case involves a foreign attachment writ issued in Pennsylvania
- Defendant was an inhabitant of Pennsylvania at time of writ issuance
Procedural posture
- Whether foreign attachment was properly issued against an inhabitant
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Foreign attachment cannot be maintained against an inhabitant; only domestic attachment applies
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Standards of review
- Validity of foreign attachment writ — de novo Legal question of whether attachment was properly issued under Pennsylvania law
Timeline
Procedural path
Foreign attachment writ issued returnable to December term
Outcome: Writ issued
Initiation of the attachment proceeding that is being challenged
Rule to show cause why foreign attachment writ should not be quashed argued
Procedural challenge to the attachment that led to this appeal
Defendant Foreman was at Lancaster, Pennsylvania, on his way to Fort Pitt, intending to proceed to Spanish settlement below Natchez on Mississippi
Shows defendant was still within Pennsylvania and had not yet emigrated
Defendant was actually at Fort Pitt
Demonstrates defendant had not yet left Pennsylvania territory at time relevant to attachment
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
4 facts- Defendant Foreman was at Lancaster on December 5, 1789, on his way to Fort Pitt
- Defendant intended to proceed to Spanish settlement below Natchez on Mississippi
- Defendant was actually at Fort Pitt on January 2, 1790
- Foreign attachment writ issued while defendant was still an inhabitant of Pennsylvania
Procedural history
3 steps- Foreign attachment issued returnable to December 1789 term
- Rule to show cause why writ should not be quashed argued
- Evidence presented about defendant's location and intentions
Evidence in the record
- Testimony that defendant was at Lancaster on December 5, 1789
- Testimony that defendant intended to proceed to Spanish settlement below Natchez
- Testimony that defendant was at Fort Pitt on January 2, 1790
- Foreign attachment writ issued returnable to December 1789 term
Authorities
Cited authorities (3)
Statutes
- Pennsylvania domestic attachment laws
- Pennsylvania foreign attachment laws
Standards & doctrines
- Inhabitant status determines attachment type
- Foreign attachment unavailable against current inhabitants
Legal principles applied
- Person remaining in state is inhabitant regardless of stated intention to leave
- Foreign attachment requires defendant to have notoriously emigrated and settled elsewhere