Overview
Case summary
This 1794 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involved a dispute over the interpretation of the act of Assembly for recording mortgages. The defendants' mortgage was recorded after six lunar months but within six calendar months from its date. The key issue was whether 'months' in the act meant lunar months or calendar months. The court, comparing this act with other legislative acts, held that calendar months were intended, thereby resolving the ambiguity in favor of the defendants' recording being timely.
Abstract
The case centered on a dispute over whether "months" in the mortgage recording statute meant lunar or calendar months, as the mortgage was recorded after six lunar months but within six calendar months. The court compared the statute with other legislative acts and held that calendar months were intended. This interpretation resolved the ambiguity in favor of the recording being timely.
Opinion of the court
opinionWilson and Petersjoined by Wilson, Peters
- Comparison with other legislative acts indicates 'months' means calendar months
- Defendants' mortgage recording was timely within six calendar months
Jurisdiction
not challengedProcedural posture
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Court interpreted 'months' as calendar months based on comparison with other legislative acts
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Statutory interpretation
1Standards of review
- Interpretation of 'months' in the mortgage recording act — de novo Statutory interpretation is a question of law reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Court heard arguments on interpretation of 'months' in the mortgage recording act
Outcome: Court ruled calendar months were intended
Resolved statutory ambiguity affecting mortgage validity
Facts & evidence
Key facts
2 facts- Defendants' mortgage was recorded after six lunar months but within six calendar months from its date
- The act of Assembly for recording Mortgages (1 Vol. Ball. Edit. p. 112) used the word 'months' without specifying lunar or calendar
Disputed questions
- Whether 'months' in the act meant lunar months or calendar months
Evidence in the record
- Act of Assembly for recording Mortgages (1 Vol. Ball. Edit. p. 112)
- Other acts of the Legislature for comparison
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Statutes
- Act of Assembly for recording Mortgages (1 Vol. Ball. Edit. p. 112)
Standards & doctrines
- De novo review for statutory interpretation
Legal principles applied
- Statutory interpretation through comparison with other legislative acts