McCullum v. Coxe

Decided Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas
Decided
Judge
McKean, Chief Justice
Posture
Jury trial pending
Plaintiff (1)
McCullum
v.
Defendant (1)
Coxe
Other parties: General Forman — Assignee of the debt, Levy — Attorney for plaintiff, Ingersoll — Attorney for assignee

Overview

The court affirmed the denial of discontinuance, holding that a plaintiff cannot discontinue after a bona fide assignment of the debt for valuable consideration to a third person, and ordered the jury to be sworn to proceed with trial.

Case summary

In McCullum v. Coxe, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed whether a plaintiff could discontinue a lawsuit after assigning the debt to a third party for valuable consideration. Plaintiff McCullum had assigned a debt to General Forman before trial, and defendant Coxe had agreed to pay Forman. At trial, with the jury ready, plaintiff's attorney moved to discontinue based on a power of attorney. The assignee's attorney opposed. Chief Justice McKean denied discontinuance, holding that a plaintiff cannot discontinue after a bona fide assignment, as the beneficial interest vests in the assignee. The court emphasized that assignments of choses in action are protected, assignees are liable for costs, and collusive settlements cannot affect bona fide assignments. The opinion cited precedent on assignee rights and costs, and noted that equitable interests need not appear on record.

Abstract

The court held that a plaintiff cannot discontinue a lawsuit after making a bona fide assignment of the debt for valuable consideration to a third party, as the beneficial interest vests in the assignee. The trial court properly denied the discontinuance motion made just before trial and proceeded by swearing in the jury. Assignments of choses in action are protected, with assignees liable for costs, and collusive actions cannot undermine such assignments.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
McKean, Chief Justice
  • Plaintiff cannot discontinue after bona fide assignment of debt
  • Beneficial interest vests in assignee and is protected by courts
  • Assignee liable to set-off and costs as if action in his name
  • Equitable interest need not appear on record
  • Collusive settlements not allowed to affect bona fide assignments

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Common law action on a debt
Jurisdictional facts
  • Action brought in Pennsylvania court
  • Issue involves assignment of debt and discontinuance

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Jury trial pending
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal from trial court ruling
Preserved issues
  • Motion to discontinue after assignment of debt

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Trial court
Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas
Trial court judge
McKean, Chief Justice
Decided
Opinion author
McKean, Chief Justice
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
McKean, Chief Justice

Issues & holdings

1
Issues raised
1
affirmed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Court held discontinuance not allowed because beneficial interest vested in assignee

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Discontinuance after assignment
A plaintiff cannot discontinue after a bona fide assignment of the debt for valuable consideration to a third person
Beneficial interest vests in assignee; assignee is protected by courts; assignor is regarded as third person; collusive settlements not allowed to affect bona fide assignments
unanimousbinding precedent
Assignment of chose in action
Beneficial interest vested in assignee of a chose in action is fully recognized and protected by courts of law and chancery
Assignee liable to set-off and costs as if action instituted in his name; equitable interest need not appear on record; assignor not liable for costs if transfer bona fide before suit
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Plaintiff's motion to discontinue after assignment of debt — procedural · error foundNot applicable as error was corrected by court denial · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
Common law principles on assignment and discontinuance
Question
Whether assignment precludes plaintiff's discontinuance
Court's reading
Assignment transfers beneficial interest, preventing plaintiff from discontinuing
Canons applied
Protection of bona fide assignmentsPrevention of collusive settlements

Standards of review

  • Discontinuance after assignment of debt — de novo Legal issue involving assignment and discontinuance reviewed de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Debt assignedMotion to discontinueDiscontinuance deniedTrial proceeds
3
Events
Before trial — Trial date
Span
Before trialfactual eventcited in opinion

Plaintiff McCullum assigned the debt to General Forman for valuable consideration

Assignment transferred beneficial interest to General Forman

Discontinuance after assignment
McCullum · General Forman
Trial datetrial eventcited in opinion

Jury at the bar to try the issue when Levy moved to discontinue based on power of attorney from plaintiff

Outcome: Motion opposed by Ingersoll for General Forman

Court considered whether plaintiff could discontinue after bona fide assignment

Discontinuance after assignment
Levy · Ingersoll · McKean, Chief Justice · jury Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas trial court
Trial daterulingcited in opinion

Court denied discontinuance, ordered jury to be sworn, and observed that actions brought for use of third person should be noted on docket

Outcome: Discontinuance denied, trial to proceed

Established that plaintiff cannot discontinue after bona fide assignment of debt

Discontinuance after assignmentAssignment of chose in action
McKean, Chief Justice Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas trial court

Facts & evidence

Key facts

5 facts
  1. Plaintiff McCullum assigned a debt to General Forman for valuable consideration before trial
  2. Defendant Coxe had undertaken to pay the debt to General Forman
  3. Plaintiff granted a power of attorney to Levy to discontinue the case
  4. Motion to discontinue was made when jury was at the bar to try the issue
  5. Ingersoll opposed discontinuance on behalf of General Forman, the assignee

Procedural history

4 steps
  1. Plaintiff assigned debt to General Forman before suit
  2. Suit brought by McCullum against Coxe
  3. Motion to discontinue made at trial
  4. Court denied discontinuance and ordered jury to be sworn

Evidence in the record

Testimonial
  • Arguments by Levy and Ingersoll at trial
Documentary
  • Power of attorney granted by plaintiff for discontinuance
  • Assignment of debt to General Forman

Jury

Verdict
Not reached due to preliminary ruling on discontinuance
Jury instructions given
  • Court ordered jury to be sworn after denying discontinuance

Authorities

Cited authorities (7)

Canby v. Ridgway, 1 Binn. 496
followedprecedent
Cited for permitting defendant to suggest on record that suit was for use of third person and ruling him to pay costs
Corser v. Craig, 1 W. C. C. 428
citedquotedpersuasive
Cited in note by Judge Washington on whether interest of cestui que trust must appear in pleadings
Whether it is necessary that the interest of the cestui que trust should be mentioned in the writ and declaration, need not be determined, because, if such be the rule, it is sufficient, if it appears in any part of the pleadings.
Reigart v. Ellmaker, 6 S. & R. 45
followedprecedent
Cited for holding that equitable interest need not appear on record
Wistar v. Walker, 2 Bro. 171
followedprecedent
Cited for rule that nominal plaintiff not liable for costs if transfer bona fide before suit
Steele v. Phœnix Co. 3 Binn. 306
citedprecedent
Cited for admission of nominal plaintiff as witness on payment of costs after assignment
Browne v. Weir, 5 S. & R. 401
citedprecedent
Cited for admission of nominal plaintiff as witness on payment of costs after assignment
North Turner, 9 Id. 244
citedprecedent
Cited for admission of nominal plaintiff as witness on payment of costs after assignment

Statutes

  • Common law on assignment and discontinuance

Standards & doctrines

  • Protection of assignee's beneficial interest
  • Prevention of collusive settlements affecting assignments

Legal principles applied

  • Assignor regarded as third person after assignment
  • Assignee liable to set-off and costs as if action in his name
Index terms65
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
trial court ruling denying discontinuance
Appealed from
Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas
Context
Court affirmed denial of plaintiff's motion to discontinue after bona fide assignment of debt, holding plaintiff cannot discontinue in such circumstances
Scope
full
Further instructions
Ordered jury to be sworn to proceed with trial
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Mckean
Courts
Practice areas
Other index terms