Overview
Case summary
In McCullum v. Coxe, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court addressed whether a plaintiff could discontinue a lawsuit after assigning the debt to a third party for valuable consideration. Plaintiff McCullum had assigned a debt to General Forman before trial, and defendant Coxe had agreed to pay Forman. At trial, with the jury ready, plaintiff's attorney moved to discontinue based on a power of attorney. The assignee's attorney opposed. Chief Justice McKean denied discontinuance, holding that a plaintiff cannot discontinue after a bona fide assignment, as the beneficial interest vests in the assignee. The court emphasized that assignments of choses in action are protected, assignees are liable for costs, and collusive settlements cannot affect bona fide assignments. The opinion cited precedent on assignee rights and costs, and noted that equitable interests need not appear on record.
Abstract
The court held that a plaintiff cannot discontinue a lawsuit after making a bona fide assignment of the debt for valuable consideration to a third party, as the beneficial interest vests in the assignee. The trial court properly denied the discontinuance motion made just before trial and proceeded by swearing in the jury. Assignments of choses in action are protected, with assignees liable for costs, and collusive actions cannot undermine such assignments.
Opinion of the court
opinionMcKean, Chief Justice
- Plaintiff cannot discontinue after bona fide assignment of debt
- Beneficial interest vests in assignee and is protected by courts
- Assignee liable to set-off and costs as if action in his name
- Equitable interest need not appear on record
- Collusive settlements not allowed to affect bona fide assignments
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Action brought in Pennsylvania court
- Issue involves assignment of debt and discontinuance
Procedural posture
- Motion to discontinue after assignment of debt
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Court held discontinuance not allowed because beneficial interest vested in assignee
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Plaintiff's motion to discontinue after assignment of debt — procedural · error foundNot applicable as error was corrected by court denial · not applicable
Statutory interpretation
1Standards of review
- Discontinuance after assignment of debt — de novo Legal issue involving assignment and discontinuance reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Plaintiff McCullum assigned the debt to General Forman for valuable consideration
Assignment transferred beneficial interest to General Forman
Jury at the bar to try the issue when Levy moved to discontinue based on power of attorney from plaintiff
Outcome: Motion opposed by Ingersoll for General Forman
Court considered whether plaintiff could discontinue after bona fide assignment
Court denied discontinuance, ordered jury to be sworn, and observed that actions brought for use of third person should be noted on docket
Outcome: Discontinuance denied, trial to proceed
Established that plaintiff cannot discontinue after bona fide assignment of debt
Facts & evidence
Key facts
5 facts- Plaintiff McCullum assigned a debt to General Forman for valuable consideration before trial
- Defendant Coxe had undertaken to pay the debt to General Forman
- Plaintiff granted a power of attorney to Levy to discontinue the case
- Motion to discontinue was made when jury was at the bar to try the issue
- Ingersoll opposed discontinuance on behalf of General Forman, the assignee
Procedural history
4 steps- Plaintiff assigned debt to General Forman before suit
- Suit brought by McCullum against Coxe
- Motion to discontinue made at trial
- Court denied discontinuance and ordered jury to be sworn
Evidence in the record
- Arguments by Levy and Ingersoll at trial
- Power of attorney granted by plaintiff for discontinuance
- Assignment of debt to General Forman
Jury
- Court ordered jury to be sworn after denying discontinuance
Authorities
Cited authorities (7)
Statutes
- Common law on assignment and discontinuance
Standards & doctrines
- Protection of assignee's beneficial interest
- Prevention of collusive settlements affecting assignments
Legal principles applied
- Assignor regarded as third person after assignment
- Assignee liable to set-off and costs as if action in his name