Overview
Case summary
In Donaldson versus Chambers (1788), the defendant was discharged under Maryland's general insolvent law but was later arrested in York County, Pennsylvania, at the plaintiff's suit. The case was brought to the Pennsylvania appellate court, where the defendant's attorney moved for discharge on common bail, citing the precedent Miller versus Hall. The court granted a Rule Nisi, indicating a temporary ruling in favor of discharge based on that authority. The case involves issues of interstate recognition of insolvency discharges and the application of precedent in early American law.
Abstract
Defendant, discharged under one state's general insolvent law, was arrested in another state at plaintiff's suit, prompting a motion for discharge on common bail citing prior precedent. The appellate court granted a Rule Nisi, temporarily ruling in favor of discharge based on that authority. The case addresses interstate recognition of insolvency discharges and precedent in early American law.
Opinion of the court
opinionNot specifiedjoined by Not specified
- Defendant discharged under Maryland insolvent law
- Defendant arrested in Pennsylvania
- Motion for discharge on common bail filed citing Miller versus Hall
- Rule Nisi granted
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Defendant was arrested in York County, Pennsylvania, at suit of plaintiff
- Cause brought into this Court (Pennsylvania appellate court)
Procedural posture
- Motion for discharge based on Maryland insolvent law discharge
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
Not specified (likely de novo for legal issue of discharge effect)
Motion based on authority of Miller versus Hall precedent
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Statutory interpretation
1Standards of review
- Discharge on common bail based on Maryland insolvent law — de novo Legal issue of effect of out-of-state discharge likely reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Defendant came into Pennsylvania
Defendant entered jurisdiction where arrest occurred
Defendant arrested in York County, Pennsylvania, at suit of plaintiff
Outcome: Defendant arrested
Initiation of legal action leading to appeal
Cause brought into this Court (Pennsylvania appellate court)
Outcome: Case transferred to appellate court
Appellate review of arrest and discharge motion
Kittera moved that defendant should be discharged on common bail, citing Miller versus Hall, 1 Dall. Rep. 229.
Outcome: Rule Nisi granted
Motion filed based on precedent, leading to temporary rule
Defendant discharged under general insolvent law of Maryland
Establishes defendant's prior legal discharge from insolvency in Maryland
Facts & evidence
Key facts
3 facts- Defendant was duly discharged under general insolvent law of Maryland
- Defendant came into Pennsylvania
- Defendant was arrested in York County, Pennsylvania, at suit of plaintiff
Procedural history
6 steps- Defendant discharged under Maryland insolvent law
- Defendant entered Pennsylvania
- Defendant arrested in York County, Pennsylvania
- Cause brought to this Court
- Motion for discharge on common bail filed
- Rule Nisi granted
Evidence in the record
- General insolvent law of Maryland
- Evidence type: Maryland insolvent law discharge · Challenge basis: Effect in Pennsylvania jurisdiction · Trial court ruling: admitted · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
Policy considerations
- Interstate recognition of insolvency discharges
- Uniformity in application of state laws across jurisdictions
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Related cases (1)
Statutes
- General insolvent law of Maryland
Standards & doctrines
- Precedent of Miller versus Hall applied
Legal principles applied
- Precedent controls similar legal issues
- State insolvent laws provide discharge from debts
Notable quotes
“The defendant was duly discharged under the general insolvent law of Maryland; but coming into Pennsylvania, was arrested in York County, at the suit of the plaintiff.”majority — Opening factual statementSets up conflict between Maryland discharge and Pennsylvania arrest