Overview
Case summary
Ralston, as assignee of bankrupt Dewhurst, brought an action for money had and received against Bell, who had sold Dewhurst's goods under authority. At trial, evidence showed Bell had not received any money at the time the action was commenced. The defendant objected that the action could not be maintained on this evidence. The plaintiff's counsel cited Douglas 132 but ultimately submitted to the court's inclination, resulting in a non-suit. On appeal, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed, holding that an action for money had and received requires the defendant to have actually received money; without receipt at the time of action, the claim fails as a matter of law.
Abstract
Assignee of a bankrupt brought an action for money had and received against a defendant who sold the bankrupt's goods under authority. Evidence showed the defendant had not received any money at the time the action commenced, leading to a non-suit after objection. The appellate court affirmed, holding that such an action requires the defendant to have actually received money at the time of commencing the action.
Opinion of the court
opinionChief Justice McKeanjoined by Justice Shippen, Justice Yeates
- Action for money had and received requires actual receipt of money
- Without receipt at time of action, claim cannot be maintained
- Plaintiff properly submitted to court's inclination
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Action brought in Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas
- Appeal to Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Procedural posture
- Whether action for money had and received could be maintained when no money received at time of action
Subsequent history
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Action requires money to have been received; without receipt, action cannot be maintained
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Trial court's inclination that action could not be maintained without money receipt — procedural · no error foundNot applicable as no error found · not applicable
Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Whether action for money had and received could be maintained when no money received at time of action — de novo Legal question about elements of cause of action reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Trial in Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas where evidence showed no money received by defendant at time action commenced
Outcome: Non-suit entered after plaintiff submitted to court's inclination
Key factual basis for legal issue about when action for money had and received can be maintained
Facts & evidence
Key facts
3 facts- Ralston, as assignee of Dewhurst (a bankrupt), brought action against Bell
- Bell sold goods of the bankrupt under authority from Dewhurst
- No money had been received by Bell at time action commenced
Procedural history
4 steps- Action for money had and received filed in Court of Common Pleas
- Defendant objected that action could not be maintained based on evidence
- Plaintiff submitted to court's inclination and suffered non-suit
- Appeal to Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Evidence in the record
- Evidence that no money had been received by defendant at time of commencing action
- Authority from Dewhurst to Bell to sell goods
- Evidence type: Testimonial evidence about lack of money receipt · Challenge basis: Legal sufficiency · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Evidence was relevant to whether action could be maintained · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
Jury
Objects of relevance
Policy considerations
- Importance of actual receipt requirement in money had and received actions
- Judicial efficiency in resolving legally insufficient claims early
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Related cases (1)
Standards & doctrines
- De novo review of legal questions
- Elements of common law action for money had and received
Legal principles applied
- Action for money had and received requires defendant to have actually received money
- Without receipt, action fails as matter of law
Notable quotes
“THIS was an action for money had and received, &c.”majority — Opening description of the caseIdentifies the legal nature of the action
“suffered A Non-suit”majority — Description of procedural outcomeShows plaintiff's acquiescence to court's view