Lessee of Biddle v. Shippen

Decided Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Disposition
affirmed
full scope
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Decided

Overview

The court affirmed the exclusion of the Zimmerman map as evidence and upheld the extension of the statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 to Pennsylvania, resolving the issues in favor of the evidentiary and statutory rulings.

Case summary

The case involves a property dispute in Germantown, Pennsylvania, where the plaintiff offered a map made by Zimmerman about thirty years prior as evidence to determine lot lines. The defendant's counsel, Mr. Ghew, initially objected but later admitted the lands were as depicted, with a reservation. The court ruled the map was not proper evidence and excluded it from jury consideration. Additionally, the court addressed the applicability of the statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 (regarding twenty years' possession) to Pennsylvania, holding that it extends there, as its provisions are contained in a local act from 1713. The case centers on evidentiary rulings and statutory interpretation in an early American property law context.

Abstract

The case centers on a property dispute where a historical map was offered as evidence to determine lot lines, but the court excluded it from jury consideration after objection and partial admission by the opposing party. The court also ruled that the English statute on twenty years' possession extends to the jurisdiction through a local act. These evidentiary and statutory rulings were upheld in favor of exclusion and applicability.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
  • The Zimmerman map is not admissible as evidence.
  • Statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 applies to Pennsylvania.

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Full case name
The Lessee of Biddle v. Shippen
Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Decided
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
Mckean

Issues & holdings

2
Issues raised
2
affirmed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

abuse of discretion

Disposition rationale

The court ruled the map was not proper evidence and upheld the trial court's exclusion.

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

The court declared that the statute extends to Pennsylvania, citing precedent and noting its provisions are contained in the act of 27th March 1713.

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Admissibility of the Zimmerman map
The map is not proper evidence and should not be given to the jury.
The court found the map, made about thirty years ago and offered through testimony of Zimmerman's nephew, was not reliable or admissible under evidentiary standards.
binding precedent
Application of statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16
The statute extends to Pennsylvania.
The court declared it had never been doubted, and its provisions are contained in the act of 27th March 1713, referencing Morris v. Vanderen where Chief Justice McKean noted it was not in force but its provisions were enacted locally.
binding precedent

Error analysis

  • Trial court erred in excluding the Zimmerman map as evidence. — evidentiary · no error foundNot applicable as no error found. · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
21 Jac. I., c. 16
Question
Whether the statute extends to Pennsylvania.
Court's reading
The statute extends to Pennsylvania, as its provisions are contained in the act of 27th March 1713.
Canons applied
Historical incorporation
legislative history considered

Standards of review

  • Admissibility of the Zimmerman map — abuse of discretion Evidentiary rulings are typically reviewed for abuse of discretion.
  • Application of statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 to Pennsylvania — de novo Statutory interpretation is reviewed de novo.

Timeline

Procedural path

Map creationMap offered as evidenceTrial court exclusion
2
Events
-11,048
Days, incident to ruling
— circa 1743
Span
trial eventcited in opinion

Trial court hears evidence, including the Zimmerman map, and rules it is not proper evidence, prohibiting it from being given to the jury.

Outcome: Map excluded as evidence

Key evidentiary ruling challenged the admissibility of the map.

Evidentiary ruling on map
Plaintiff · Defendant · Mr. Ghew · Court Pennsylvania Supreme Court trial court
circa 1743factual eventcited in opinion

Zimmerman creates a map of Germantown at the request of the people of Germantown, depicting lot lines and adjacent out-lands.

Outcome: Map created

The map was later offered as evidence in the case to determine property lines.

Evidentiary ruling on map
Zimmerman · people of Germantown Germantown not applicable

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
Germantown, Pennsylvania

Key facts

4 facts
  1. The plaintiff offered a map made by Zimmerman about thirty years ago as evidence.
  2. John Knorr, Zimmerman's nephew, testified that the map was made at the request of the people of Germantown, remained in the family after Zimmerman's death, and was used to resolve disputes about property lines.
  3. Mr. Ghew, opposing counsel, initially objected to the map but later admitted the lands in controversy were as depicted, with a reservation that it not set a precedent.
  4. The court ruled the map was not proper evidence and prohibited it from being given to the jury.

Evidence in the record

Physical
  • Zimmerman map of Germantown
Testimonial
  • Testimony of John Knorr about the map's creation and use
Documentary
  • Map of Germantown
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Map of Germantown · Challenge basis: reliability and admissibility · Trial court ruling: excluded · Reasoning: Court ruled it was not proper evidence and should not be given to the jury. · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed
Excluded
  • Evidence type: Zimmerman map · Exclusion basis: Not proper evidence under evidentiary standards

Objects of relevance

Map of Germantown showing lot lines and out-lands

Authorities

Cited authorities (3)

Morris v. Vanderen, post, p. 67
distinguishedquotedprecedent
Cited for discussion on statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 not being in force in Pennsylvania but its provisions enacted locally.
C. J. McKean said, that the statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16, was not in force in Pennsylvania. Its principal provisions are contained in the act of 27th March 1713.
Griffith v. Tunckhouser, 1 Peters’ C. C. 418
citedpersuasive
Cited as reference on evidentiary matters.
Jones v. Bache, 3 W. C. C. 199
citedpersuasive
Cited as reference on evidentiary matters.

Related cases (3)

Morris v. Vanderen, post, p. 67
prior appeal
Cited for discussion on statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 not being in force but its provisions enacted locally.
Griffith v. Tunckhouser, 1 Peters’ C. C. 418
related prosecution
Cited as reference on evidentiary matters.
Jones v. Bache, 3 W. C. C. 199
related prosecution
Cited as reference on evidentiary matters.

Statutes

  • 21 Jac. I., c. 16
  • Act of 27th March 1713

Standards & doctrines

  • Abuse of discretion for evidentiary rulings
  • De novo review for statutory interpretation

Legal principles applied

  • Evidentiary reliability
  • Statutory incorporation through local acts

Notable quotes

“the statute of 21 Jac. I., c. 16, of twenty years’ possession, extended here; and that it had never been doubted”
majority — Discussion on the applicability of the statute to Pennsylvania.
Affirms the extension of English statute to colonial Pennsylvania.
“the statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16, was not in force in Pennsylvania. Its principal provisions are contained in the act of 27th March 1713.”
C. J. McKean (cited in opinion) — Reference to Morris v. Vanderen regarding the statute's status.
Clarifies that while the statute itself might not be in force, its provisions were enacted locally.
Index terms64
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
trial court's evidentiary ruling excluding the map
Appealed from
trial court
Context
The court affirmed the exclusion of the Zimmerman map as evidence, ruling it was not proper evidence.
Scope
full
Action type
affirmed
Target
application of statute 21 Jac. I., c. 16 to Pennsylvania
Appealed from
trial court
Context
The court affirmed that the statute extends to Pennsylvania, citing historical incorporation.
Scope
full
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Mckean
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms