Overview
Case summary
In Stieber v. Hoye, the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia addressed a priority dispute between a fieri facias (execution) and an attachment for rent not due. The marshal received an execution at the suit of Shuck against a lessee before an attachment was issued under a Virginia statute to secure rent not yet due. The marshal attached the lessee's goods and levied the execution on the same goods. The court held that the execution, having been received first, was entitled to priority and must be satisfied before the attachment, as no rent was due at the time of the execution's receipt. The decision establishes precedent on the timing-based priority of execution over attachment for future rent.
Abstract
The court addressed a priority dispute between a fieri facias execution received by the marshal and a subsequent attachment issued to secure rent not yet due on the same goods. It held that the execution, received first, took priority and must be satisfied before the attachment, as no rent was due at the time of the execution's receipt. This decision establishes precedent on timing-based priority of execution over attachments for future rent.
Opinion of the court
opinionTHE COURTjoined by THE COURT
- Execution received before attachment has priority
- No rent due at time of execution receipt
- Execution must be first satisfied
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Case heard in Circuit Court, District of Columbia during October Term 1801
Procedural posture
- Priority of fieri facias over attachment for rent not due
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Execution received prior to attachment issuance has priority under law
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Standards of review
- Priority of execution over attachment — de novo Legal issue of priority reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Marshal received fieri facias (execution) at suit of Shuck against lessee before attachment for rent not due was issued
Execution received prior to attachment establishes timing for priority analysis
Attachment issued under Virginia act to secure rent not due, and marshal attached goods and levied execution on same goods
Creates conflict over which claim has priority to the goods
Circuit Court decided execution has priority over attachment and must be first satisfied
Outcome: Execution granted priority
Court's holding on priority issue
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
4 facts- Marshal received a fieri facias (execution) at suit of Shuck against a lessee before an attachment for rent not due was issued
- Attachment was issued under Virginia act of assembly (Rev. Code, p. 102, § S) to secure rent not due
- Marshal attached goods and chattels of the lessee and levied the fi. fa. on the same goods
- No rent was due at time of receipt of the execution
Procedural history
2 steps- Marshal returned attachment and execution on same goods
- Dispute arose over priority of satisfaction
Evidence in the record
- Fieri facias (execution) document
- Attachment document under Virginia act
- Marshal's return on attachment and execution
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Statutes
- Virginia act of assembly (Rev. Code, p. 102, § S) for attachment to secure rent not due
Standards & doctrines
- Priority doctrine based on timing of receipt
Legal principles applied
- First in time, first in right principle for execution vs. attachment