Overview
Case summary
In Nesbit versus Pope, the defendant had obtained a rule to try or non pros at a prior term. At the current term, the defendant's counsel forgot this rule and requested the plaintiff to continue the cause, which was agreed to and entered by the Prothonotary. Upon immediately discovering the mistake, the defendant notified the plaintiff and insisted on the rule. When the cause was called, the defendant moved to order it on, but the plaintiff objected, arguing the entry of continuance was conclusive. The court held that the entry was not conclusive as it was a mere mistake, promptly corrected with no inconvenience to the plaintiff, and reversed the plaintiff's objection.
Abstract
Defendant obtained a prior rule to try or non pros but counsel forgot it and agreed to a continuance entry, which was promptly corrected upon discovery with no inconvenience to plaintiff. Plaintiff argued the continuance entry was conclusive, but the court held it was a mere mistake. The court reversed plaintiff's objection and allowed enforcement of the original rule.
Opinion of the court
opinionBy the Court:
- The entry of continuance cannot be conclusive.
- It was a mere mistake, immediately discovered and notified.
- No inconvenience arose from it for the plaintiff.
- If the plaintiff had suffered harm, it might be different, but here he could suffer nothing.
- If the plaintiff was ready for trial when the entry was made, he must be ready when the mistake was notified.
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
The court held the entry was not conclusive as it was a mere mistake, immediately discovered and notified, causing no inconvenience to the plaintiff.
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Standards of review
- Whether the entry of continuance is conclusive — de novo The court reviewed the legal effect of the entry as a matter of law.
Timeline
No timeline recorded.
Facts & evidence
Key facts
5 facts- At a former term, the defendant obtained a rule to try or non pros against the plaintiff.
- At this term, the defendant's counsel, not recollecting the rule, requested the plaintiff to continue the cause, which the plaintiff agreed to.
- The Prothonotary entered a continuance accordingly.
- Immediately after, the defendant discovered the rule and notified the plaintiff's counsel, insisting on the rule.
- The cause was called, and the defendant moved to order it on, while the plaintiff objected, arguing the entry of continuance was conclusive.
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Standards & doctrines
- de novo review of legal effect
Legal principles applied
- Court entries due to mistake are not conclusive if no harm results