Overview
Case summary
In GUION v. M’CULLOUGH et al. (1791), the plaintiff sued defendants on a bond for $1,000. The writ was filled up as 'that they answer unto him of a plea of debt of one thousand dollars.' Defendants filed a plea in abatement, arguing the writ did not run in the usual form 'in the debet and detinet.' Plaintiff demurred. The Circuit Court (Justices Iredell and Sit-Greaves) overruled the plea, holding the writ sufficient because it agreed with ac etiam clauses in actions of debt under English practice, citing Page v. Farmer. The court affirmed the writ's validity, establishing precedent on the form of writs in debt actions.
Abstract
Plaintiff sued defendants on a bond for debt via a writ specifying a plea of debt. Defendants filed a plea in abatement claiming the writ deviated from the usual "debet et detinet" form, but plaintiff demurred. The court overruled the plea, holding the writ sufficient as it aligned with English practice precedents in debt actions.
Opinion of the court
opinionIREDELL, Circuit Justice, and SIT-GREAVES, District Judge
- Writ in debt 'that they answer unto him of a plea of debt of one thousand dollars' is sufficient
- Form agrees with ac etiam clauses in English practice
- Plea in abatement overruled
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Action on a bond for $1,000
- Filed in Circuit Court, D. North Carolina
Procedural posture
- Form of writ in action of debt
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Court held writ sufficient as it agreed with ac etiam clauses in English practice
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Standards of review
- Form of writ in action of debt — de novo Legal question regarding sufficiency of writ form
Timeline
Procedural path
Circuit Court overruled plea in abatement and held writ sufficient
Outcome: Plea in abatement overruled
Court established precedent on form of writ in action of debt
Facts & evidence
Key facts
4 facts- Plaintiff GUION sued defendants M’CULLOUGH et al. on a bond with penalty of $1,000
- Writ was filled up as 'that they answer unto him of a plea of debt of one thousand dollars'
- Defendants filed plea in abatement arguing writ did not run in usual form 'in the debet and detinet'
- Plaintiff filed general demurrer to plea in abatement
Procedural history
4 steps- Plaintiff filed action on bond
- Defendants filed plea in abatement challenging form of writ
- Plaintiff demurred to plea in abatement
- Court overruled plea and held writ sufficient
Evidence in the record
- Bond with penalty of $1,000
- Writ filled up as 'that they answer unto him of a plea of debt of one thousand dollars'
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (1)
Standards & doctrines
- English practice in writ drafting
Legal principles applied
- Writ form sufficient if it agrees with ac etiam clauses in English practice