Fitzalden v. Lee

Decided Not specifiedCourt of Common Pleas (Pennsylvania)
Disposition
reversed
full scope
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Court of Common Pleas (Pennsylvania)
Decided
Not specified
Posture
Judgment rendered for Lee after jury awarded possession
Plaintiff in error (1)
Fitzalden
Ingersoll
v.
Defendant in error (1)
Lee
Sergeant

Overview

Motion for writ of restitution refused.

Case summary

Fitzalden and Lee had a controversy over a tract of land in Luzerne county. They agreed to try the right to possession in a summary manner in the Court of Common Pleas, with proceedings drawn up as if under the landlord and tenant act. A jury awarded possession to Lee, judgment was rendered for him, and a writ of possession was issued, turning Fitzalden out and putting Lee in possession. On error, the judgment was reversed. Lee then moved for a writ of restitution. The court held that while execution is of right, it may be withheld on proper reasons. The defendant was in possession under the plaintiff's agreement, and it would be fraudulent to overthrow the agreement in this manner. Under all circumstances, the court refused to issue the writ of restitution.

Abstract

Parties disputed possession of a tract of land and agreed to resolve it summarily in court under landlord-tenant procedures, resulting in a jury verdict and writ of possession awarding possession to one party. The judgment was reversed on error, prompting a motion for a writ of restitution to restore possession. The court refused the writ, holding that execution may be withheld for proper reasons, including the original agreement under which the defendant held possession, deeming it fraudulent to overthrow that agreement.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
By the Court:
  • Execution is of right but may be withheld on proper reasons
  • Defendant in possession under agreement with plaintiff
  • Fraudulent to attempt to overthrow agreement in this manner
  • Under circumstances, not proper to issue writ of restitution

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Error proceeding from summary trial under landlord and tenant act
Jurisdictional facts
  • Controversy about a tract of land in Luzerne county
  • Agreement to try right to possession in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Judgment rendered for Lee after jury awarded possession
Posture on appeal
Writ of error
Preserved issues
  • Propriety of issuing writ of restitution

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Full case name
Fitzalden versus Lee
Court
Court of Common Pleas (Pennsylvania)
Decided
Not specified
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential

Issues & holdings

1
Issues raised
1
affirmed
1
Holdings
Standard of review

Discretionary

Disposition rationale

Court exercised discretion to refuse writ due to fraudulent attempt to overthrow agreement and equitable considerations

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Propriety of issuing writ of restitution after judgment reversal
Court refused to issue writ of restitution
Execution is of right but may be withheld on proper reasons; defendant in possession under agreement with plaintiff; fraudulent for any man to attempt to overthrow his agreement in this manner; under all circumstances, not proper to issue writ
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Original judgment based on summary proceedings under landlord and tenant act — procedural · error foundJudgment reversed on error · not harmless

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
Landlord and tenant act
Question
Whether summary proceedings under act were proper for land possession dispute
Court's reading
Proceedings drawn up as if under act, but judgment reversed on error
Canons applied
Equitable construction

Standards of review

  • Issuance of writ of restitution — abuse of discretion Court has discretion to withhold execution on proper reasons being shown

Timeline

Procedural path

Summary trial agreementJury possession awardJudgment renderedWrit of possession executedJudgment reversed on appealMotion for restitutionMotion refused
7
Events
Not specified — Not specified
Span
Not specifiedprocedural eventcited in opinion

Plaintiff and defendant agree to try right to possession of land in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas

Establishes basis for summary proceedings under landlord and tenant act

Fitzalden · Lee trial court
Not specifiedtrial eventcited in opinion

Jury awards possession to Lee in summary trial

Outcome: Possession awarded to Lee

Leads to judgment for Lee and writ of possession

Jury · Fitzalden · Lee trial court
Not specifiedprocedural eventcited in opinion

Judgment rendered for Lee based on jury verdict

Outcome: Judgment for Lee

Formal court judgment awarding possession

Court of Common Pleas trial court
Not specifiedprocedural eventcited in opinion

Writ of possession issued, Fitzalden turned out and Lee put into possession

Outcome: Lee gains possession of land

Execution of judgment through writ of possession

Fitzalden · Lee
Not specifiedappeal eventcited in opinion

Error brought, judgment reversed by appellate court

Outcome: Judgment reversed

Original judgment invalidated on appeal

Fitzalden · Lee · Ingersoll appellate court
Not specifiedmotioncited in opinion

Sergeant moves for writ of restitution for Lee

Motion seeking to restore Lee to possession after reversal

Sergeant · Court appellate court
Not specifiedrulingcited in opinion

Court refuses motion for writ of restitution

Outcome: Motion refused

Court exercises discretion to deny restitution despite reversal

Court appellate court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
Luzerne county

Key facts

7 facts
  1. Plaintiff and defendant had controversy about a tract of land
  2. They agreed to try right to possession in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas
  3. Proceedings drawn up as if plaint under landlord and tenant act
  4. Jury awarded possession to Lee
  5. Judgment rendered for Lee
  6. Writ of possession issued, Fitzalden turned out and Lee put into possession
  7. Judgment reversed on error

Procedural history

6 steps
  1. Summary trial in Court of Common Pleas
  2. Jury awarded possession to Lee
  3. Judgment rendered for Lee
  4. Writ of possession issued
  5. Error brought, judgment reversed
  6. Motion for writ of restitution filed

Evidence in the record

Documentary
  • Agreement to try right to possession in summary manner
  • Proceedings drawn up as if plaint under landlord and tenant act

Authorities

Cited authorities (4)

9 Vin. 589. 90
citedprecedent
Cited by Sergeant to support that restitution is of duty
1 Hawk. 140. feel. 64. 65.
citedprecedent
Cited by Ingersoll to argue restitution not ex rigors juris and arises from equitable construction
Mitford, 103.
citedprecedent
Cited by Ingersoll to support equitable interposition to prevent injustice
1 Vol Dall. Edit. p. 617
citedprecedent
Referenced regarding court not assuming powers of Court of Chancery

Statutes

  • Landlord and tenant act

Standards & doctrines

  • Execution may be withheld on proper reasons
  • Equitable construction of statutes

Legal principles applied

  • Court may withhold execution on proper reasons
  • Agreements should not be fraudulently overthrown
Index terms74
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
reversed
Target
Judgment for Lee
Appealed from
Court of Common Pleas
Context
Judgment reversed on error brought by Fitzalden
Scope
full
Action type
denied
Target
Motion for writ of restitution
Appealed from
Appellate court
Context
Court refused motion for writ of restitution after judgment reversal
Scope
full
Search facets
Parties
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms