Overview
Case summary
Fitzalden and Lee had a controversy over a tract of land in Luzerne county. They agreed to try the right to possession in a summary manner in the Court of Common Pleas, with proceedings drawn up as if under the landlord and tenant act. A jury awarded possession to Lee, judgment was rendered for him, and a writ of possession was issued, turning Fitzalden out and putting Lee in possession. On error, the judgment was reversed. Lee then moved for a writ of restitution. The court held that while execution is of right, it may be withheld on proper reasons. The defendant was in possession under the plaintiff's agreement, and it would be fraudulent to overthrow the agreement in this manner. Under all circumstances, the court refused to issue the writ of restitution.
Abstract
Parties disputed possession of a tract of land and agreed to resolve it summarily in court under landlord-tenant procedures, resulting in a jury verdict and writ of possession awarding possession to one party. The judgment was reversed on error, prompting a motion for a writ of restitution to restore possession. The court refused the writ, holding that execution may be withheld for proper reasons, including the original agreement under which the defendant held possession, deeming it fraudulent to overthrow that agreement.
Opinion of the court
opinionBy the Court:
- Execution is of right but may be withheld on proper reasons
- Defendant in possession under agreement with plaintiff
- Fraudulent to attempt to overthrow agreement in this manner
- Under circumstances, not proper to issue writ of restitution
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Controversy about a tract of land in Luzerne county
- Agreement to try right to possession in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas
Procedural posture
- Propriety of issuing writ of restitution
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
Discretionary
Court exercised discretion to refuse writ due to fraudulent attempt to overthrow agreement and equitable considerations
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Original judgment based on summary proceedings under landlord and tenant act — procedural · error foundJudgment reversed on error · not harmless
Statutory interpretation
1Standards of review
- Issuance of writ of restitution — abuse of discretion Court has discretion to withhold execution on proper reasons being shown
Timeline
Procedural path
Plaintiff and defendant agree to try right to possession of land in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas
Establishes basis for summary proceedings under landlord and tenant act
Jury awards possession to Lee in summary trial
Outcome: Possession awarded to Lee
Leads to judgment for Lee and writ of possession
Judgment rendered for Lee based on jury verdict
Outcome: Judgment for Lee
Formal court judgment awarding possession
Writ of possession issued, Fitzalden turned out and Lee put into possession
Outcome: Lee gains possession of land
Execution of judgment through writ of possession
Error brought, judgment reversed by appellate court
Outcome: Judgment reversed
Original judgment invalidated on appeal
Sergeant moves for writ of restitution for Lee
Motion seeking to restore Lee to possession after reversal
Court refuses motion for writ of restitution
Outcome: Motion refused
Court exercises discretion to deny restitution despite reversal
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
7 facts- Plaintiff and defendant had controversy about a tract of land
- They agreed to try right to possession in summary manner in Court of Common Pleas
- Proceedings drawn up as if plaint under landlord and tenant act
- Jury awarded possession to Lee
- Judgment rendered for Lee
- Writ of possession issued, Fitzalden turned out and Lee put into possession
- Judgment reversed on error
Procedural history
6 steps- Summary trial in Court of Common Pleas
- Jury awarded possession to Lee
- Judgment rendered for Lee
- Writ of possession issued
- Error brought, judgment reversed
- Motion for writ of restitution filed
Evidence in the record
- Agreement to try right to possession in summary manner
- Proceedings drawn up as if plaint under landlord and tenant act
Authorities
Cited authorities (4)
Statutes
- Landlord and tenant act
Standards & doctrines
- Execution may be withheld on proper reasons
- Equitable construction of statutes
Legal principles applied
- Court may withhold execution on proper reasons
- Agreements should not be fraudulently overthrown