Overview
Case summary
This 1786 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involved a writ of error brought by Sliver to reverse a judgment entered against him in the Common Pleas of Philadelphia County while he was an infant (under 21). The record showed Sliver appeared in person, then said nothing (nil dicit), resulting in judgment against him. After attaining full age, Sliver challenged the judgment, arguing his appearance as an infant was error. The court held that an infant's appearance in a lawsuit is not a judicial act and that a judgment against an infant can be reversed after full age, with the fact of infancy to be tried by jury rather than by inspection. The court reversed the judgment below, establishing precedent on infants' capacity to appear in court and challenge judgments entered during minority.
Abstract
Plaintiff, as an infant under 21, appeared in person in a lawsuit but said nothing, leading to a default judgment (nil dicit) against him. After reaching full age, he brought a writ of error challenging the judgment on grounds of infancy. The court held that an infant's appearance is not a judicial act, reversed the judgment, and ruled that the fact of infancy must be tried by jury rather than by mere inspection.
Opinion of the court
opinionMcKean, Chief Justice
- Appearance of infant is not judicial act
- Judgment against infant can be reversed after full age
- Infancy must be tried per pais (by jury) not by inspection
- Distinguishes between judicial acts (guardian appointment) and non-judicial acts (appearance)
- Cites common law and statutory authorities
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Judgment entered against Sliver in common pleas court
- Sliver brought writ of error after attaining full age
Procedural posture
- Whether appearance of infant by attorney is error
- Whether judgment against infant can be reversed after full age
Subsequent history
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Appearance of infant is not a judicial act; judgment can be reversed after full age
Issue preserved for review
de novo
Fact of infancy must be tried per pais and not by inspection
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Appearance of infant by attorney (or in person) in lawsuit — procedural · error foundNot analyzed - error required reversal · not applicable
Statutory interpretation
2Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Whether appearance of infant is judicial act and whether judgment can be reversed after full age — de novo Legal interpretation of common law and statutes regarding infants' appearances
Timeline
Procedural path
Supreme Court hears arguments on writ of error regarding judgment against infant
Outcome: Court reverses judgment below
Establishes that appearance of infant is not judicial act and can be reversed after full age
Suit brought against Sliver in Common Pleas of Philadelphia County while Sliver was an infant
Outcome: Sliver appeared in person, then nil dicit; judgment entered against Sliver
Forms basis for writ of error regarding infant's appearance
Sliver attained full age (21 years)
Outcome: Sliver reached majority
Enabled Sliver to bring writ of error challenging judgment entered during infancy
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
4 facts- Sliver was an infant (under 21) when suit was brought against him
- Record stated Sliver appeared in person, imparled to next term, then appeared and said nothing (nil dicit)
- Judgment was entered against Sliver
- Sliver attained full age before bringing writ of error
Disputed questions
- Whether Sliver's appearance was a judicial act
- Whether infancy could be tried by inspection or per pais
Procedural history
5 steps- Suit brought against Sliver in Common Pleas of Philadelphia County
- Sliver appeared in person, then nil dicit
- Judgment entered against Sliver
- Sliver attained full age
- Sliver brought writ of error to reverse judgment
Evidence in the record
- Record stating Sliver appeared in person, imparled to next term, then appeared and said nothing
- Court record from Common Pleas of Philadelphia County
Jury
Sentencing
Objects of relevance
Policy considerations
- Protection of infants from legal proceedings during minority
- Balance between finality of judgments and protection of vulnerable parties
Authorities
Cited authorities (14)
Related cases (1)
Statutes
- Statute of Westminster II, chapter 15
- Statute of Westminster II, chapter 10
Standards & doctrines
- Common law rules on attorney representation
- Distinction between judicial and non-judicial acts
Legal principles applied
- Infants require protection in legal proceedings
- Judicial acts cannot be reversed after full age but non-judicial acts can
Notable quotes
“At the common law, there could be no appearance in any suit, real, personal or mixed, whether as plaintiff or defendant, but in proper person”McKean, Chief Justice — Explaining common law rule on appearancesEstablishes baseline rule that infants cannot appear by attorney
“The appearance of an infant to a suit brought against him, is not a judicial act”McKean, Chief Justice — Holding on nature of infant's appearanceKey distinction allowing reversal of judgment after full age
“Let the judgment below be reversed”McKean, Chief Justice — Final dispositionCourt's mandate reversing trial court judgment