Overview
Case summary
This is an ejectment case from 1801 in the Circuit Court for the District of Columbia. Plaintiff Stephen Cooke sued defendant Nicholas Voss to recover possession of a lot of land. Cooke had conveyed the lot to Edward Ramsay in 1795 with an annual rent obligation and a clause allowing re-entry if rent was in arrears for 30 days with insufficient goods for distress. Ramsay conveyed to Voss. Rent for 1797 and 1798 was unpaid. On January 31, 1798, Cooke demanded rent on the lot and re-entered due to non-payment and lack of goods for distress. Voss argued the re-entry was invalid due to various procedural defects. The jury found a special verdict with the facts, and the court entered judgment for Cooke. The court held that in such ejectment actions, the plaintiff need not prove fee simple title if showing long possession (44 years), need not show insufficient goods for distress within the first 30 days, need not demand rent on the due date, and need not specify where on the lot rent was demanded. The judgment for plaintiff was affirmed.
Abstract
Plaintiff sued for ejectment to recover possession of a lot after conveying it with an annual rent obligation and a re-entry clause for non-payment. Defendant contested the re-entry's validity due to procedural defects, but the court held that in ejectment actions, plaintiff need not prove fee simple title with long possession, show insufficient goods for distress within 30 days, demand rent on the due date, or specify the demand location on the lot. Judgment for plaintiff was affirmed.
Opinion of the court
opinion
- Plaintiff need not show fee title with 44-year possession
- No requirement to show insufficient goods for distress within first 30 days
- No requirement to demand rent on due date
- No requirement to specify location of demand on lot
Jurisdiction
not challenged- Case heard in Circuit Court, District of Columbia
Procedural posture
- Sufficiency of evidence for re-entry for non-payment of rent
- Requirements for demand of rent
- Title proof in ejectment
Subsequent history
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Plaintiff need not show fee title if he shows possession of forty-four years
Issue preserved for review
de novo
No such showing required
Issue preserved for review
de novo
No such demand required
Issue preserved for review
de novo
No such specification required
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Defendant claimed re-entry was unlawful due to insufficient proof of title, improper demand timing, and improper demand location — procedural · no error foundnot applicable
Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Legal requirements for ejectment upon re-entry for non-payment of rent — de novo Questions of law regarding pleading and proof requirements are reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
William Thornton Alexander conveys lot to Stephen Cooke by deed of bargain and sale
Establishes Cooke's initial ownership of the lot
Stephen Cooke conveys lot to Edward Ramsay in fee simple with annual rent of £16 Virginia currency due January 1, containing distress and re-entry clause
Creates landlord-tenant relationship with rent obligation and forfeiture provisions
Rent of £10 becomes due from Ramsay to Cooke
First rent payment that falls into arrears, leading to eventual re-entry
Rent of £10 becomes due from Ramsay to Cooke
Second rent payment that falls into arrears, compounding the default
Stephen Cooke goes upon the lot about 15 minutes before sunset, demands payment of £16 rent due 1797-01-01 and £10 rent due 1798-01-01, remains until after sunset, and re-enters due to non-payment and no goods for distress
Attempted exercise of re-entry right under deed, central to ejectment claim
Nicholas Voss first has notice of demand of rent and re-entry
Timing of defendant's awareness of plaintiff's actions
Nicholas Voss has kiln of bricks worth $300 and erects buildings worth $600 on the lot
Shows defendant's use and investment in property after re-entry
Circuit Court, District of Columbia issues judgment for plaintiff Cooke in ejectment action
Outcome: Judgment for plaintiff
Final disposition of the case at trial level
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
8 facts- William Thornton Alexander possessed lot for about 44 years before 1794
- Alexander conveyed lot to Stephen Cooke on 1794-12-25
- Cooke conveyed lot to Edward Ramsay on 1795-05-25 with rent of £16 Virginia currency yearly due January 1
- Deed contained distress and re-entry clause if rent in arrear 30 days and insufficient goods for distress
- Ramsay conveyed to Nicholas Voss
- Rent of £10 due 1797-01-01 and £10 due 1798-01-01 was in arrear
- On 1798-01-31, Cooke demanded rent on lot about 15 minutes before sunset, remained until after sunset, re-entered due to non-payment and no goods for distress
- Voss had kiln of bricks worth $300 and built buildings worth $600 on lot in summer 1798
Disputed questions
- Whether re-entry was lawful
- Whether demand of rent was properly made
- Whether plaintiff's title was sufficient
Procedural history
3 steps- Ejectment action filed by Cooke against Voss
- Jury trial with special verdict
- Judgment for plaintiff Cooke
Evidence in the record
- Deed from Alexander to Cooke dated 1794-12-25
- Deed from Cooke to Ramsay dated 1795-05-25 with rent and re-entry clause
- Kiln of bricks worth $300 on lot in summer 1798
- Buildings erected worth $600 on lot in summer 1798
- Jury's special verdict detailing facts
- Deeds conveying the lot
- Lease agreement with rent terms
- Possession of lot for about 44 years by Alexander and successors
- Rent in arrear for 1797 and 1798
Jury
- Instructions on special verdict form
Objects of relevance
Policy considerations
- Courts should not impose overly technical requirements that would undermine landlord's re-entry rights for non-payment of rent
Authorities
Cited authorities (6)
Standards & doctrines
- De novo review of legal requirements in ejectment
Legal principles applied
- Long-term possession (44 years) is sufficient to support ejectment without proving fee title
- Technical requirements for demand and re-entry should not be overly strict
Notable quotes
“In ejectment upon re-entry for non-payment of rent by tenant in fee, the plaintiff need not show that his own title was in fee, if he shows a possession of forty-four years”majority — Court's holding on title proof requirementEstablishes that long possession can substitute for formal title proof in ejectment