Bell v. Andrews

Decided Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Court of Common Pleas (nisi prius)
Decided
Judge
By the Court
Posture
Verdict for plaintiff after jury trial
Defendant (1)
Andrews
S. Levy
v.
Plaintiff (1)
Bell
Hallowell

Overview

The court affirmed the trial court's ruling, overruling the objection to parol evidence and holding that an action for damages lies for breach of a parol agreement for sale of land where consideration has been paid.

Case summary

Bell v. Andrews is a 1796 Pennsylvania Supreme Court case involving a breach of contract dispute over a parol agreement for the sale of land. The plaintiff, Bell, sued Andrews for damages after Andrews refused to convey land following Bell's payment under a verbal agreement. At trial, the defendant objected to parol evidence of the agreement, citing Pennsylvania's act for prevention of frauds and perjuries. The trial court overruled the objection, admitted the evidence, and the jury found for the plaintiff. On appeal, the Supreme Court affirmed, holding that parol evidence is admissible to prove such agreements and payment, and that an action for damages lies for non-performance, as the act does not void parol agreements but only restricts the acquisition of an interest in land. The court distinguished the case from those requiring part performance, noting the agreement was not void ab initio.

Abstract

In a breach of contract dispute over a verbal agreement for the sale of land, the defendant objected to parol evidence under the act for prevention of frauds and perjuries, but the trial court admitted it and the jury ruled for the plaintiff. On appeal, the Supreme Court affirmed, holding that parol evidence is admissible to prove such agreements and payment, and that an action for damages is available for non-performance since the act does not void parol agreements but only restricts acquiring an interest in land. The court distinguished the case from those requiring part performance, noting the agreement was not void ab initio.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
By the Courtjoined by McKean, Shippen, Smith
  • Parol evidence admissible for land sale agreements
  • Act of assembly does not void parol agreements
  • Action for damages lies for non-performance
  • English statute of frauds not extended to Pennsylvania

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Action on the case for breach of contract
Jurisdictional facts
  • Trial at nisi prius in Pennsylvania
  • Verdict for plaintiff
  • Appeal on evidentiary ruling

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Verdict for plaintiff after jury trial
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal from trial court ruling
Preserved issues
  • Objection to parol evidence of agreement for sale of land

Legal categories

BusinessEstate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Court
Pennsylvania Supreme Court
Trial court
Court of Common Pleas (nisi prius)
Trial court judge
McKean, Chief Justice, and Shippen and Smith, Justices
Decided
Opinion author
By the Court
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
McKeanShippenSmith

Issues & holdings

1
Issues raised
1
affirmed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Parol evidence is admissible; act of assembly does not make parol agreements void, only restricts acquisition of interest in land; action for damages lies

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Admissibility of parol evidence for land sale agreement
Parol evidence is admissible to prove agreement and payment of consideration for sale of land
Act of assembly does not make parol agreements void; English statute of frauds never extended to Pennsylvania; payment may be proved by parol evidence
unanimousbinding precedent
Actionability of parol agreement for sale of land
Action will lie to recover damages for non-performance of parol agreement for sale of land
Agreement not rendered void by act; though it restricts acquisition of interest in land, damages are recoverable for breach
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Trial court erred in admitting parol evidence of agreement for sale of land — evidentiary · no error foundNot applicable as no error found · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
Pennsylvania act for prevention of frauds and perjuries (1 Dali. Laws, 640 ; 1 Sm. Laws, 389)
Question
Whether act voids parol agreements for sale of land
Court's reading
Act does not void parol agreements; only restricts acquisition of interest in land, but damages are recoverable for breach
Canons applied
Plain meaningLegislative intent
no legislative history

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Preponderance of evidence for breach of contract
Burden met
true

Standards of review

  • Admissibility of parol evidence and legal effect of parol agreement — de novo Legal interpretation of statute and common law principles

Timeline

Procedural path

Trial conductedObjection raisedObjection overruledVerdict enteredAppeal prompted
trial eventcited in opinion

Trial at nisi prius before Chief Justice McKean and Justices Shippen and Smith; verdict for plaintiff Bell

Outcome: Verdict for plaintiff

Trial court overruled objection to parol evidence, leading to appeal

Admissibility of parol evidence for land sale agreement
Bell · Andrews · McKean · Shippen · Smith · Hallowell · S. Levy Pennsylvania trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
Westmoreland county, Pennsylvania

Key facts

5 facts
  1. Parol agreement for sale of land in fee-simple
  2. Payment of price by plaintiff
  3. Defendant acknowledged sale and payment
  4. Defendant refused to execute conveyance
  5. Plaintiff sued for damages for non-performance

Procedural history

3 steps
  1. Trial at nisi prius on August 26, 1796
  2. Verdict for plaintiff
  3. Appeal on evidentiary ruling

Evidence in the record

Testimonial
  • Parol evidence of agreement
  • Evidence of payment of price
  • Evidence of defendant's acknowledgment and refusal
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Parol evidence of agreement for sale of land · Challenge basis: Act for prevention of frauds and perjuries requiring writing · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Act does not make parol agreements void · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed

Jury

Verdict
For plaintiff
Verdict date
1796-08-26
Jury instructions given
  • Not specified in opinion

Objects of relevance

Tract of land in Westmoreland county

Authorities

Cited authorities (9)

Ewing v. Tees, 1 Binn. 460
followedquotedprecedent
Cited for recovery of damages on parol contracts for sale of land
at 1 Binn. 460 Chief Justice Tilghman says, 'in several cases at nisi prius, damages have been recovered on parol contracts for the sale of land.'
Ellet v. Paxson, 2 W. & S. 418
citedprecedent
Cited for measure of damages
at 2 W. & S. 418
Meason v. Kaine, 63 Penn. St. 335; s. c. 67 Id. 126
citedprecedent
Cited for measure of damages
at 63 Penn. St. 335; 67 Id. 126
Bouser v. Cessna, 62 Penn. St. 148
citedprecedent
Cited for measure of damages
at 62 Penn. St. 148
Harris v. Harris, 70 Penn. St. 170
citedprecedent
Cited for measure of damages
at 70 Penn. St. 170
McCafferty v. Griswold, 29 Pitts L. J. 269
citedprecedent
Cited for measure of damages (nominal damages if no expenses incurred)
at 29 Pitts L. J. 269
Clyde v. Clyde, 1 Yeates 92
citedprecedent
Cited in headnotes
at 1 Yeates 92
Sedam v. Shaffer, 5 W. & S. 529
citedprecedent
Cited in headnotes
at 5 W. & S. 529
Thompson v. Sheplar, 72 Penn. St. 160
citedprecedent
Cited in headnotes
at 72 Penn. St. 160

Related cases (9)

Ewing v. Tees, 1 Binn. 460
prior appeal
Supports recovery of damages on parol contracts for sale of land
Clyde v. Clyde, 1 Yeates 92
prior appeal
Cited in headnotes
Sedam v. Shaffer, 5 W. & S. 529
prior appeal
Cited in headnotes
Meason v. Kaine, 63 Penn. St. 335; s. c. 67 Id. 126
prior appeal
Cited for measure of damages and in headnotes
Thompson v. Sheplar, 72 Penn. St. 160
prior appeal
Cited in headnotes
Ellet v. Paxson, 2 W. & S. 418
prior appeal
Cited for measure of damages
Bouser v. Cessna, 62 Penn. St. 148
prior appeal
Cited for measure of damages
Harris v. Harris, 70 Penn. St. 170
prior appeal
Cited for measure of damages
McCafferty v. Griswold, 29 Pitts L. J. 269
prior appeal
Cited for measure of damages (nominal damages if no expenses incurred)

Statutes

  • Pennsylvania act for prevention of frauds and perjuries (1 Dali. Laws, 640 ; 1 Sm. Laws, 389)

Standards & doctrines

  • Parol evidence rule
  • Statute of frauds doctrine

Legal principles applied

  • Parol evidence admissible to prove payment in executed agreements
  • Statute does not void parol agreements but limits land interest

Notable quotes

“The payment of the consideration-money may, certainly, be proved by parol evidence.”
majority — Ruling on admissibility of evidence
Establishes parol evidence rule exception for payment in land sale contracts
“But, certainly, an action will lie to recover damages for the non-performance of such an agreement.”
majority — Holding on actionability of parol agreement
Confirms damages recoverable for breach of parol land sale contract
Index terms75
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
trial court judgment
Appealed from
Court of Common Pleas (nisi prius)
Context
The court affirmed the trial court's overruling of the objection to parol evidence and the verdict for the plaintiff, holding that parol evidence is admissible and an action for damages lies for breach of the agreement.
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
MckeanShippenSmith
Courts
Locations
Statutes cited
Practice areas
Other index terms