M'Grath v. Candalero

8,810
Decided District Court, D. South Carolina
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Decided
Judge
BEE, District Judge
Posture
Decree entered in favor of libelant
Defendant (1)
Candalero
v.
Libelant (1)
M’Grath
Other parties: Henri Hervieux — Defendant

Overview

The motion to review the decree and discharge the attached property is denied, as the court has jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts in admiralty cases, and the motion is untimely after the writ of error was lodged.

Case summary

This 1794 admiralty case involves a libel by M’Grath against the sloop Candalero and Henri Hervieux for damages from the illegal seizure of the schooner Polly and her cargo on the high seas. After the court decided in favor of M’Grath, a motion was filed to review the decree and discharge the attached property. The court addressed two issues: (1) whether admiralty courts have jurisdiction to proceed by attachment in rem for torts, holding that they do under the judiciary act, as attachment secures redress when the party cannot be personally reached, and there is no distinction between tort and contract cases; and (2) whether the motion to review is timely after a writ of error has been lodged, holding it is not, as issues should have been raised before the decree, and review is only allowed for errors on the record or new matter discovered. The motion was denied.

Abstract

In this admiralty case, a libel was filed against a sloop and individual for damages from the illegal seizure of a schooner and cargo on the high seas, with the court initially ruling in favor of the libellant. The court upheld its jurisdiction to proceed by attachment in rem for torts, equivalent to contract cases, as it secures redress when personal service is unavailable. A subsequent motion to review the decree and discharge the attached property was denied as untimely after a writ of error was lodged, with issues required to be raised prior to the decree.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
BEE, District Judge
  • Admiralty courts have jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases under the judiciary act
  • Attachment is appropriate to secure redress when the party cannot be personally reached
  • Motion to review is untimely after writ of error lodged unless error on record or new matter discovered

Jurisdiction

challenged
Statutory basis
9th section of the judiciary act
Subject matter
Exclusive original cognizance of all civil causes of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction
Jurisdictional holding
The court has jurisdiction to proceed by attachment in rem for torts in admiralty cases
Jurisdictional facts
  • The case involves a tort (illegal seizure of a schooner and cargo) occurring on the high seas

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Decree entered in favor of libelant
Posture on appeal
Motion to review and discharge property attached
Preserved issues
  • Jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts
  • Timeliness of motion to review after writ of error lodged

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
M’GRATH v. CANDALERO
Docket number
8,810
Court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Trial court
District Court, D. South Carolina
Trial court judge
BEE, District Judge
Decided
Opinion author
BEE, District Judge
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
BEE, District Judge

Issues & holdings

2
Issues raised
2
affirmed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Court finds jurisdiction exists under the judiciary act for admiralty matters, including torts

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Court finds the motion is too late as it could have been raised before the decree passed

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases
Admiralty courts have jurisdiction to proceed by attachment in rem for torts
The judiciary act grants exclusive original cognizance of admiralty matters; attachment is appropriate to secure redress when the party cannot be personally reached, and there is no reason to distinguish between debt/contract and tort cases
unanimousbinding precedent
Timeliness of motion to review
A motion to review a decree must fail after a writ of error has been lodged, unless error appears on the face of the record or new matter is discovered
Parties had opportunity to raise issues before decree; forgetfulness or negligence is not grounds for review; only errors apparent on the record or new matter discovered since the decree justify review
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Lack of jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts — procedural · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable
  • Motion to review filed after writ of error lodged — procedural · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
9th section of the judiciary act
Question
Whether it grants jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases in admiralty
Court's reading
It grants exclusive original cognizance of admiralty matters, including jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases
Canons applied
Plain meaning
no legislative history

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Preponderance of evidence for civil admiralty claim
Burden met
true

Standards of review

  • Jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts — de novo Jurisdictional questions are reviewed de novo
  • Timeliness of motion to review — de novo Procedural timeliness is reviewed de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Motion filedCourt hearingMotion denied
rulingcited in opinion

Court hears motion to review decree and discharge attached property, denies motion on both jurisdictional and timeliness grounds

Outcome: Motion denied

Establishes admiralty court jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases and timeliness rules for review motions

Jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for tortsTimeliness of motion to review
BEE, District Judge · M’Grath · Candalero · Henri Hervieux District Court, D. South Carolina trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Location
High seas

Key facts

3 facts
  1. Libelant M’Grath filed a libel against the sloop Candalero and Henri Hervieux for damages due to illegal seizure of the schooner Polly and her cargo
  2. The court previously decided in favor of libelant
  3. A motion was filed to review the decree and discharge the attached property

Disputed questions

  • Whether the court has jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts
  • Whether the motion to review is timely

Procedural history

3 steps
  1. Libel filed for damages from illegal seizure
  2. Court decided in favor of libelant
  3. Motion to review filed after decree and writ of error lodged

Evidence in the record

Direct
  • Libel for damages from illegal seizure of schooner Polly and cargo
Documentary
  • Decree from prior decision
  • Writ of error lodged

Objects of relevance

Sloop CandaleroSchooner Polly and her cargo (subject of illegal seizure)

Policy considerations

  • Ensuring remedies are available for torts in admiralty to avoid 'a right without a remedy'
  • Promoting finality in decrees by limiting review to errors on the record or new matter

Authorities

Cited authorities (3)

Le Caux and Eden
followedprecedent
Cited to support that common law allows actions for seizing ships on high seas
Viu. Abr. tit. “Chancery” (Z,) par. IS
appliedquotedprecedent
Cited for principle that forgetfulness or negligence is no ground for bill of review
that “forgetfulness or negligence of parties is no foundation for a bill of review”
Gilb. Eq. 184
appliedquotedprecedent
Cited for rule that review only allowed for errors on record or new matter discovered
“Matters which might have been put in issue in the original cause, shall never be examined on bill of review. Bill of review Is allowed only ou errors apparent upon the face of the record, or on new matter discovered since the decree.”

Related cases (2)

The Bremena v. Card, 38 Fed. 145
subsequent appeal
Cited this case
The New England, Case No. 10.151
subsequent appeal
Cited this case

Statutes

  • 9th section of the judiciary act (grants admiralty jurisdiction)

Standards & doctrines

  • De novo review for jurisdictional and procedural issues

Legal principles applied

  • Attachment is appropriate for torts as for debts/contracts in admiralty
  • Review only allowed for errors on record or new matter discovered

Notable quotes

““If an alien sue here for a tort under the law of nations or a treaty of the United States, against a citizen of the United States, the suit will be sustained. Shall it be otherwise, where the alien is the offender, and one of our citizens the party complaining?””
BEE, District Judge — Discussing jurisdiction for attachment in tort cases
Highlights equity and consistency in admiralty jurisdiction between citizens and aliens
““Matters which might have been put in issue in the original cause, shall never be examined on bill of review. Bill of review is allowed only on errors apparent upon the face of the record, or on new matter discovered since the decree.””
BEE, District Judge — Discussing timeliness of motion to review
Establishes strict limits on grounds for reviewing decrees
Index terms66
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
Jurisdiction to proceed by attachment for torts
Appealed from
Motion to review
Context
Court affirms its jurisdiction under the judiciary act to use attachment in rem for torts in admiralty cases
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Action type
denied
Target
Motion to review decree and discharge property
Appealed from
Motion to review
Context
Court denies the motion as untimely after writ of error lodged, since issues could have been raised before decree and no error on record or new matter exists
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
Bee
Courts
Locations
Statutes cited
Practice areas
Other index terms