Overview
Case summary
This 1798 U.S. Supreme Court case involved a property dispute over a will in Connecticut. The Court of Probate initially disapproved the will, but the Connecticut Legislature passed a resolution granting a new hearing, which resulted in approval of the will. Calder et al., who would have inherited if the will remained disapproved, appealed, arguing the legislative resolution was an unconstitutional ex post facto law. The Court held that the ex post facto clause applies only to criminal laws, not civil matters affecting property rights. The Court also found that Connecticut's Legislature historically exercised judicial power in granting new trials, making its action permissible under state usage. The judgment of the Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors was affirmed.
Abstract
In a property dispute over a will, a probate court initially disapproved the will, but the state legislature passed a resolution granting a new hearing that resulted in approval. Heirs who would have inherited absent the will appealed, claiming the resolution was an unconstitutional ex post facto law. The U.S. Supreme Court held the ex post facto clause applies only to criminal laws, not civil property matters, and affirmed the legislature's action as permissible under historical state judicial practices.
Opinion of the court
opinionPaterson, Justicejoined by Chase, Justice, Iredell, Justice, Cushing, Justice
- Ex post facto laws limited to criminal matters
- Connecticut Legislature exercised judicial power based on usage
- Resolution did not violate U.S. Constitution
Concurring opinions
1Jurisdiction
not challenged- Case brought in error from State of Connecticut
- Involves interpretation of ex post facto clause in U.S. Constitution
Procedural posture
- Whether Connecticut legislative resolution is an ex post facto law under U.S. Constitution
Subsequent history
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Ex post facto laws refer only to criminal matters, not civil cases affecting property rights
Issue preserved for review
de novo
Legislature exercised judicial authority based on state constitutional usage
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Error analysis
- Connecticut Legislature passed an ex post facto law by granting new trial after decree — constitutional · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable
Statutory interpretation
1Burden of proof
Standards of review
- Interpretation of ex post facto clause — de novo Constitutional interpretation reviewed de novo
- Nature of legislative act — de novo Characterization of state action as judicial or legislative reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Normand Morrison (grandson) makes will
Outcome: Will created
Foundation for property dispute
Court of Probate for Hartford disapproves will of Normand Morrison
Outcome: Will disapproved, property rights vested in Calder et Wife
Initial determination of property rights
Connecticut Legislature passes resolution setting aside probate decree and granting new hearing
Outcome: New hearing ordered
Legislative intervention in judicial matter
New hearing before Court of Probate approves will
Outcome: Will approved, property rights transferred to Bull et Wife
Reversal of initial probate decision
Superior court at Hartford affirms probate decree
Outcome: Affirmed
Intermediate appellate review
Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirms, finding no errors
Outcome: Affirmed
State high court decision appealed to U.S. Supreme Court
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
8 facts- Normand Morrison (grandson) made will on August 21, 1779
- Court of Probate for Hartford disapproved will on March 21, 1793
- Connecticut Legislature passed resolution on May 1795 setting aside probate decree and granting new hearing
- New hearing held on July 27, 1795 approving will
- Appeal to superior court affirmed probate decree in February 1796
- Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirmed in June 1796
- Calder and wife claim property as heirs of N. Morrison, physician
- Bull and wife claim under will of N. Morrison, grandson
Disputed questions
- Whether legislative resolution was judicial or legislative act
- Whether resolution affected vested rights
Procedural history
6 steps- March 21, 1793: Court of Probate disapproves will
- May 1795: Connecticut Legislature passes resolution granting new hearing
- July 27, 1795: New hearing approves will
- February 1796: Superior court affirms probate decree
- June 1796: Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirms
- 1798: U.S. Supreme Court hears appeal
Evidence in the record
- Will of Normand Morrison
- Court of Probate decree
- Connecticut legislative resolution
- Superior court decision
- Supreme Court of Errors decision
Objects of relevance
Policy considerations
- Danger of legislative abuse through ex post facto criminal laws
- Need to protect personal security from retrospective punishment
- Balance between legislative power and individual rights in civil matters
- Respect for state constitutional practices and usages
Authorities
Cited authorities (2)
Related cases (2)
Statutes
- U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 10 (ex post facto prohibition)
- Connecticut statutes on probate and appeals
Standards & doctrines
- Ex post facto doctrine limited to criminal matters
- Political-process doctrine not applicable
- Judicial review of legislative acts
Legal principles applied
- Ex post facto prohibition applies only to criminal laws
- State constitutional usage can establish legislative judicial authority
- Retrospective civil laws not per se unconstitutional
Notable quotes
“The words, ex post facto, when applied to a law, have a technical meaning, and, in legal phraseology, refer to crimes, pains, and penalties.”Paterson, Justice — Defining scope of ex post facto clauseEstablishes limited application to criminal matters
“Every ex post facto law must necessarily be retrospective; but every retrospective law is not an ex post facto law.”Chase, Justice — Distinguishing between types of retrospective lawsClarifies constitutional prohibition does not cover all retrospective laws