Calder v. Wife

Not specified
Decided Supreme Court of the United States
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut
Decided
Judge
Paterson, Justice
Posture
Decree of Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirming lower court decision
Plaintiffs in error (1)
Calder et Wife
The Council for the Plaintiffs in error
v.
Defendants in error (1)
Bull et Wife

Overview

Judgment affirmed. The Connecticut legislative resolution was not an ex post facto law, and the Legislature acted within its judicial capacity under state constitutional usage.

Case summary

This 1798 U.S. Supreme Court case involved a property dispute over a will in Connecticut. The Court of Probate initially disapproved the will, but the Connecticut Legislature passed a resolution granting a new hearing, which resulted in approval of the will. Calder et al., who would have inherited if the will remained disapproved, appealed, arguing the legislative resolution was an unconstitutional ex post facto law. The Court held that the ex post facto clause applies only to criminal laws, not civil matters affecting property rights. The Court also found that Connecticut's Legislature historically exercised judicial power in granting new trials, making its action permissible under state usage. The judgment of the Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors was affirmed.

Abstract

In a property dispute over a will, a probate court initially disapproved the will, but the state legislature passed a resolution granting a new hearing that resulted in approval. Heirs who would have inherited absent the will appealed, claiming the resolution was an unconstitutional ex post facto law. The U.S. Supreme Court held the ex post facto clause applies only to criminal laws, not civil property matters, and affirmed the legislature's action as permissible under historical state judicial practices.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
Paterson, Justicejoined by Chase, Justice, Iredell, Justice, Cushing, Justice
  • Ex post facto laws limited to criminal matters
  • Connecticut Legislature exercised judicial power based on usage
  • Resolution did not violate U.S. Constitution

Concurring opinions

1
Concurring Iredell, Justice

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Statutory basis
Constitution of the United States, Article I, Section 10
Subject matter
Appeal from state court decision involving federal constitutional question
Jurisdictional holding
Jurisdiction exercised to review state legislative act under federal Constitution
Jurisdictional facts
  • Case brought in error from State of Connecticut
  • Involves interpretation of ex post facto clause in U.S. Constitution

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Decree of Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirming lower court decision
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal on writ of error
Preserved issues
  • Whether Connecticut legislative resolution is an ex post facto law under U.S. Constitution

Subsequent history

Petition for rehearing
not filed
Rehearing en banc
not filed
Petition for certiorari
not filed
Remand proceedings
Not applicable
Mandate issued
Not specified

Legal categories

Estate Planning and Real Estate

Case record

Full case name
Calder et Wife, versus Bull et Wife
Docket number
Not specified
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Trial court
Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut
Trial court judge
Not specified
Decided
Opinion author
Paterson, Justice
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
Chase, JusticePaterson, JusticeIredell, JusticeCushing, Justice

Issues & holdings

2
Issues raised
2
affirmed
3
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Ex post facto laws refer only to criminal matters, not civil cases affecting property rights

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Legislature exercised judicial authority based on state constitutional usage

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Ex post facto law prohibition
The ex post facto clause prohibits only laws that criminalize previously innocent acts, enhance crimes or penalties, or change rules of evidence for conviction; it does not apply to civil laws affecting property rights
Historical usage, state constitutions, and Blackstone's commentary confirm technical meaning limited to criminal matters; Constitution's structure separates ex post facto prohibition from contract impairment clause
unanimousbinding precedent
Connecticut legislative resolution
The Connecticut Legislature's resolution granting a new trial was not an ex post facto law because it affected civil property rights, not criminal matters
Resolution operated on judicial decree, not on acts of citizens; even if legislative, it falls outside ex post facto prohibition as applied to civil cases
unanimousbinding precedent
Judicial vs legislative power
Connecticut Legislature exercised judicial authority based on state constitutional usage allowing legislative grant of new trials
Long-standing practice establishes legislative superintendence over courts as part of state constitution; act was judicial in nature
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Connecticut Legislature passed an ex post facto law by granting new trial after decree — constitutional · no error foundNot applicable · not applicable

Statutory interpretation

1
Statute
U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 10: 'No State shall... pass any ex post facto law'
Question
Scope of ex post facto prohibition
Court's reading
Limited to criminal laws affecting crimes, pains, and penalties; does not extend to civil laws affecting property rights
Canons applied
Technical meaningHistorical usageStructural interpretation
legislative history considered

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Not applicable
Defence burden
Not applicable

Standards of review

  • Interpretation of ex post facto clause — de novo Constitutional interpretation reviewed de novo
  • Nature of legislative act — de novo Characterization of state action as judicial or legislative reviewed de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Will createdWill disapprovedLegislative resolutionNew hearingWill approvedSuperior court affirmanceSupreme Court affirmance
6
Events
6,129
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
factual eventcited in opinion

Normand Morrison (grandson) makes will

Outcome: Will created

Foundation for property dispute

Property rights under will
Normand Morrison Connecticut not applicable
procedural eventcited in opinion

Court of Probate for Hartford disapproves will of Normand Morrison

Outcome: Will disapproved, property rights vested in Calder et Wife

Initial determination of property rights

Whether legislative resolution affected vested rights
Court of Probate · Calder et Wife · Bull et Wife Hartford, Connecticut trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Connecticut Legislature passes resolution setting aside probate decree and granting new hearing

Outcome: New hearing ordered

Legislative intervention in judicial matter

Whether resolution is ex post facto lawJudicial vs legislative power
Connecticut Legislature Connecticut not applicable
procedural eventcited in opinion

New hearing before Court of Probate approves will

Outcome: Will approved, property rights transferred to Bull et Wife

Reversal of initial probate decision

Effect on vested rights
Court of Probate · Bull et Wife Hartford, Connecticut trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Superior court at Hartford affirms probate decree

Outcome: Affirmed

Intermediate appellate review

Judicial review of legislative act
Superior court Hartford, Connecticut trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirms, finding no errors

Outcome: Affirmed

State high court decision appealed to U.S. Supreme Court

Federal constitutional review
Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut Connecticut appellate court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date
Various dates between 1779-1796
Location
Hartford, Connecticut

Key facts

8 facts
  1. Normand Morrison (grandson) made will on August 21, 1779
  2. Court of Probate for Hartford disapproved will on March 21, 1793
  3. Connecticut Legislature passed resolution on May 1795 setting aside probate decree and granting new hearing
  4. New hearing held on July 27, 1795 approving will
  5. Appeal to superior court affirmed probate decree in February 1796
  6. Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirmed in June 1796
  7. Calder and wife claim property as heirs of N. Morrison, physician
  8. Bull and wife claim under will of N. Morrison, grandson

Disputed questions

  • Whether legislative resolution was judicial or legislative act
  • Whether resolution affected vested rights

Procedural history

6 steps
  1. March 21, 1793: Court of Probate disapproves will
  2. May 1795: Connecticut Legislature passes resolution granting new hearing
  3. July 27, 1795: New hearing approves will
  4. February 1796: Superior court affirms probate decree
  5. June 1796: Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut affirms
  6. 1798: U.S. Supreme Court hears appeal

Evidence in the record

Physical
  • Will of Normand Morrison
Documentary
  • Court of Probate decree
  • Connecticut legislative resolution
  • Superior court decision
  • Supreme Court of Errors decision

Objects of relevance

Will of Normand Morrison (document determining property distribution)

Policy considerations

  • Danger of legislative abuse through ex post facto criminal laws
  • Need to protect personal security from retrospective punishment
  • Balance between legislative power and individual rights in civil matters
  • Respect for state constitutional practices and usages

Authorities

Cited authorities (2)

1 Bl. Com. 46
followedquotedprecedent
Cited for Blackstone's definition of ex post facto laws
at 46 Description of ex post facto laws as punishing innocent acts
2 Lord Raymond 1352
distinguishedprior appeal
Cited as instance where statute affecting contracts was called ex post facto
at 1352 Statute about registering contracts for South Sea Stock

Related cases (2)

1 Bl. Com. 46
prior appeal
Cited for definition of ex post facto laws
2 Lord Raymond 1352
prior appeal
Cited as instance where statute called ex post facto

Statutes

  • U.S. Constitution, Article I, Section 10 (ex post facto prohibition)
  • Connecticut statutes on probate and appeals

Standards & doctrines

  • Ex post facto doctrine limited to criminal matters
  • Political-process doctrine not applicable
  • Judicial review of legislative acts

Legal principles applied

  • Ex post facto prohibition applies only to criminal laws
  • State constitutional usage can establish legislative judicial authority
  • Retrospective civil laws not per se unconstitutional

Notable quotes

“The words, ex post facto, when applied to a law, have a technical meaning, and, in legal phraseology, refer to crimes, pains, and penalties.”
Paterson, Justice — Defining scope of ex post facto clause
Establishes limited application to criminal matters
“Every ex post facto law must necessarily be retrospective; but every retrospective law is not an ex post facto law.”
Chase, Justice — Distinguishing between types of retrospective laws
Clarifies constitutional prohibition does not cover all retrospective laws
Index terms103
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
judgment of Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut
Appealed from
Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut
Context
Court affirms state court judgment, holding Connecticut legislative resolution not an ex post facto law
Scope
full
Further instructions
None
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
ChaseCushingIredellPaterson
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms