Overview
Case summary
This case involves an ejectment action between a devisee under a will and a claimant with superior title. The key issue is whether the residuary legatee, who has a remote contingent interest under the will (receiving one-fourth of purchase money if the devisee alienates the property improperly), is a competent witness for the plaintiff. The court held that the interest is too remote to presume bias, making the witness competent, with credibility determined by the jury.
Abstract
In an ejectment action, a devisee under a will sued a claimant with superior title, calling the residuary legatee—who held a remote contingent interest in purchase money if the property were improperly alienated—as a witness. The court held the interest too remote to presume bias, rendering the witness competent with credibility for the jury to assess.
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
The court ruled the witness is competent because his interest is too remote to bias his mind, leaving credibility to the jury.
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Timeline
No timeline recorded.
Facts & evidence
Key facts
3 facts- A devise (will) was made of certain premises to A, with a condition that if A alienates it to any person other than his brother's children, he must pay one-fourth of the purchase money to the testator's residuary legatee.
- An ejectment action is pending between the devisee (A) and someone claiming paramount to the devise.
- The residuary legatee was offered as a witness on behalf of the plaintiff (Galbraith’s Lessee).
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Cited authorities (12)
Standards & doctrines
- Witness competency based on remoteness of interest
Legal principles applied
- Remote interests do not presumptively bias a witness; credibility is for the jury