Overview
Case summary
This is an ejectment case from Allegheny County where the defendant, a member of the Pennsylvania General Assembly, moved to set aside a confessed judgment on the ground of legislative privilege. The defendant argued that as a legislator attending session in Philadelphia, he was privileged from having his private suits forced to trial. The court held that while legislative privilege exists to protect members from civil process during legislative sessions, the privilege must be claimed at the proper time. Here, neither the defendant nor his attorney raised the privilege objection when the cause was marked for trial or when judgment was confessed, thereby waiving the privilege. The court unanimously affirmed the judgment.
Abstract
In an ejectment action, the defendant sought to set aside a confessed judgment based on legislative privilege, claiming protection from civil suits while attending legislative sessions. The court held that although the privilege exists, it was waived because neither the defendant nor his attorney raised it when the case was marked for trial or when judgment was confessed. The judgment was unanimously affirmed and cannot now be opened or set aside.
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
No issues recorded for this case.
Timeline
No timeline recorded.
Facts & evidence
Objects of relevance
Authorities
Standards & doctrines
- legislative privilege doctrine
- waiver doctrine for privileges
Legal principles applied
- privileged person must claim benefit at proper time and manner
- waiver of privilege concludes party forever