Forrest v. Hanson

4,943
Decided Circuit Court, District of Columbia
Disposition
affirmed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Circuit Court, District of Columbia
Decided
Judge
CRANCH, Circuit Judge
Posture
Judgment for plaintiff after verdict
Defendant (1)
HANSON
Mr. Simms, Mr. Jones
v.
Plaintiff (1)
FORREST
Mr. Dennis, Mr. Gantt, Mr. C. Lee

Overview

The court affirmed the judgment for the plaintiff with full costs, holding that the words spoken of the plaintiff in his official character as a bank director were actionable slander.

Case summary

This 1802 slander case involves plaintiff Forrest, a director of the Bank of Columbia, suing defendant Hanson, the bank's cashier, for calling him 'a liar and a swindler' in discourse concerning Forrest's role as director. The Circuit Court affirmed judgment for Forrest, holding that words not actionable when spoken of a common person become actionable when spoken of an officer in relation to official conduct if they import unfitness for office. The court found the bank directorship qualifies as an office of trust, the words 'liar and swindler' import unfitness for such office, the words were spoken in colloquium concerning the office, and Forrest was entitled to full costs under the statute of Glocester rather than the inapplicable statute of James.

Abstract

Plaintiff, a bank director, sued the bank's cashier for slander after being called a "liar and a swindler" in connection with his official role. The court held that such words, not actionable against a common person, become actionable when spoken of an officer regarding official conduct if they imply unfitness for an office of trust like a bank directorship. The judgment for the plaintiff was affirmed with full costs under the applicable statute.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
CRANCH, Circuit Judgejoined by KILTY, MARSHALL
  • Words become actionable when spoken of officer in official conduct if they import unfitness for office
  • Bank directorship is office of trust
  • 'Liar and swindler' imports unfitness for bank directorship
  • Colloquium concerning office established from pleadings and words
  • Plaintiff entitled to full costs under statute of Glocester

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Subject matter
Circuit Court jurisdiction over slander action
Jurisdictional facts
  • The court has unlimited jurisdiction by amount of claim or verdict in actions of slander
  • Justices of the peace have no cognizance of actions of slander

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Judgment for plaintiff after verdict
Posture on appeal
Appeal from judgment on slander action
Preserved issues
  • Whether words spoken of an officer in official conduct are actionable
  • Whether office of director of Bank of Columbia is an office of trust
  • Whether words import unfitness for office
  • Whether colloquium concerning office was established
  • Whether plaintiff entitled to full costs

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
FORREST v. HANSON
Docket number
4,943
Court
Circuit Court, District of Columbia
Trial court
Circuit Court, District of Columbia
Trial court judge
KILTY, Chief Judge, and CRANCH and MARSHALL, Circuit Judges
Decided
Opinion author
CRANCH, Circuit Judge
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
KILTYCRANCHMARSHALL

Issues & holdings

5
Issues raised
5
affirmed
5
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Words not actionable when spoken of common person may become actionable when spoken of officer in relation to official conduct if they import unfitness for office

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Directors are entrusted with regulating bank affairs, choosing officers, determining business rules, appointing staff, and disposing of bank money and credit - making it an office of high trust and responsibility

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Charging someone as liar and swindler implies high moral depravity and fraud, incompatible with integrity required for bank director

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Declaration states plaintiff was director and words were spoken in discourse concerning him as director, and words themselves reference 'one of the directors'

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Statute of Glocester gives costs where damages recovered; statute of James not applicable in Maryland; court has unlimited jurisdiction in slander actions

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Actionability of words spoken of officer in official conduct
Words not actionable when spoken of common person may become actionable when spoken of officer in relation to official conduct if they import unfitness for office
General rule from Bacon's Abridgment: words spoken of person in office of honor, profit, or trust that import charge of unfitness to discharge duties are actionable when spoken in colloquium concerning office
unanimousbinding precedent
Status of bank director as office of trust
Office of director of Bank of Columbia is an office of trust within meaning of the law
Bank incorporation act entrusts directors with regulating bank affairs, choosing officers, determining business rules, appointing staff, and disposing of bank money and credit; comparable to other offices held actionable in precedents
unanimousbinding precedent
Import of words 'liar and swindler'
Words 'liar and swindler' import unfitness to discharge duties of bank director
Swindling implies crimes under statute 30 Geo. II c. 24 and common law cheating; implies high moral depravity and fraud incompatible with integrity required for bank director
unanimousbinding precedent
Establishment of colloquium concerning office
Words were spoken in colloquium concerning plaintiff's office as director
Declaration states plaintiff was director and words spoken in discourse concerning him as director; words themselves reference 'one of the directors'
unanimousbinding precedent
Entitlement to full costs
Plaintiff entitled to full costs under statute of Glocester
Statute of Glocester gives costs where damages recovered; statute of James not applicable in Maryland as not practiced upon; court has unlimited jurisdiction in slander actions
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Trial court erred in finding words actionable — evidentiary · no error foundNot applicable as no error found
  • Trial court erred in awarding full costs — procedural · no error foundNot applicable as no error found

Statutory interpretation

3
Statute
Statute of Glocester
Question
Whether gives costs in all cases where damages recovered
Court's reading
Gives costs in all cases where damages recovered
Canons applied
plain meaning
Statute
Statute of 21 Jac. c. 16
Question
Whether applicable in Maryland
Court's reading
Not applicable as not practiced upon in Maryland courts and of local nature applicable only to English courts
Canons applied
legislative intentlocal applicability
Statute
Statute 30 Geo. II c. 24
Question
Meaning of 'swindling' in context
Court's reading
Implies crimes of obtaining money/goods by false pretenses with intent to cheat or defraud
Canons applied
plain meaningcommon understanding

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Plaintiff must prove words were spoken, were false, caused damage, and were actionable
Burden met
true

Standards of review

  • Interpretation of whether words are actionable when spoken of officer — de novo Legal question requiring interpretation of common law principles
  • Whether office qualifies as office of trust — de novo Legal determination based on bank incorporation act and precedents
  • Meaning and import of words 'liar and swindler' — de novo Legal interpretation of words in context of official conduct
  • Whether colloquium concerning office established — de novo Legal interpretation of pleadings and words spoken
  • Entitlement to costs under applicable statutes — de novo Legal interpretation of statutory applicability

Timeline

Procedural path

Slanderous words spokenTrial court judgmentAppeal affirmed
2
Events
273
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
factual eventcited in opinion

Defendant Hanson, as cashier of Bank of Columbia, spoke words calling plaintiff Forrest 'a liar and a swindler' in discourse concerning plaintiff as director of the bank

This is the alleged slander that forms basis of the lawsuit

Whether words are actionable when spoken of officer in official conduct
HANSON · FORREST
procedural eventcited in opinion

Circuit Court hears appeal and renders opinion affirming judgment for plaintiff with full costs

Outcome: Judgment affirmed for plaintiff with full costs

Final disposition of the appeal

All issues on appeal
KILTY · CRANCH · MARSHALL trial court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date

Key facts

4 facts
  1. Plaintiff Forrest was a director of the Bank of Columbia
  2. Defendant Hanson, as cashier of the bank, spoke words about Forrest
  3. Words spoken: 'General Forrest is a liar and a swindler, and I can prove him to be so; I, as cashier, say so of one of the directors, and I think one or the other of us ought to be turned out of the bank'
  4. Action grounded on words spoken respecting plaintiff in his official character as director

Procedural history

3 steps
  1. Plaintiff filed slander action
  2. Case tried and verdict for plaintiff
  3. Defendant appealed judgment

Evidence in the record

Testimonial
  • Defendant's spoken words: 'General Forrest is a liar and a swindler, and I can prove him to be so; I, as cashier, say so of one of the directors, and I think one or the other of us ought to be turned out of the bank'
Documentary
  • Act incorporating Bank of Columbia
  • Declaration in pleadings
Challenged
  • Evidence type: Spoken words alleging plaintiff is 'liar and swindler' · Challenge basis: Whether actionable when spoken of officer in official conduct · Trial court ruling: admitted · Reasoning: Words actionable when spoken of officer if import unfitness for office · Challenged on appeal: true · Appellate outcome: affirmed

Jury

Verdict
For plaintiff
Verdict date
Before appeal

Sentencing

Sentence imposed
Judgment for plaintiff with damages and costs
Sentence type
discretionary

Objects of relevance

Bank of Columbia money and propertyBank incorporation act document

Authorities

Cited authorities (21)

4 Bac. Abr. 489
followedquotedprecedent
General rule that words spoken of person in office of honor, profit, or trust that import charge of unfitness to discharge duties are actionable when spoken in colloquium concerning office
Style, 338
followedprecedent
Words spoken of church-warden held actionable on account of office
Woodruff v. Weoley, Cart. 1
followedprecedent
Action for words spoken of church-warden; colloquium laid of office
Godb. 157, pl. 211
followedprecedent
Words spoken of town clerk held actionable
Yel. 142
followedprecedent
Words spoken of town clerk held actionable
Yel. 153
followedprecedent
Words spoken of constable held actionable
Reignald's Case, Cro. Car. 563
followedprecedent
Words spoken of deputy-clerk to arch-deacon's register held actionable
Cro. Eliz. 358
followedprecedent
Words spoken of clerk to Company of Merchant Tailors held actionable on account of office
Seaman v. Bigg, 3 Cro. Car. 480
followedprecedent
Words spoken of steward of private gentleman held actionable
Sir Richard Greenfield's Case, March, 82, pl. 135
followedprecedent
Not material what employment under king if may lose employment or trust thereby
Wright v. Moorhouse, Cro. Eliz. 358
followedprecedent
Words spoken of clerk of Merchant Tailors held actionable on account of office
Strode v. Homes, Style, 338
followedprecedent
Words spoken of church-warden held actionable on account of office
1 Term R. 733
followedprecedent
Word 'swindling' held to imply crimes for which person might be indicted
Berryman v. Wise, 4 Term R. 300
followedprecedent
Word 'swindler' actionable when applied to attorney in official character
1 Hawk. P. C. 343
followedprecedent
Describes common law offence of cheating as deceitful practices in defrauding another
6 Vin. Abr. 530
followedprecedent
Statute of James not construed to extend to courts with limited jurisdiction
Ld. Raym. 181, 182
followedprecedent
Statute of James applicable only to superior courts in England
Ld. Raym. 395
followedprecedent
If action carried up to Westminster Hall, plaintiff had full costs despite statute of James
1 Bac. Abr. 514
followedprecedent
If action carried up to Westminster Hall, plaintiff had full costs
7 Mod. 129
followedprecedent
If action carried up to Westminster Hall, plaintiff had full costs
4 Mod. 378
followedprecedent
If action carried up to Westminster Hall, plaintiff had full costs

Statutes

  • Statute of Glocester (foundation for costs in Maryland)
  • Statute of 21 Jac. c. 16 (not applicable in Maryland)
  • Statute 30 Geo. II c. 24 (defines swindling offenses)
  • Act incorporating Bank of Columbia

Standards & doctrines

  • Actionable words per se when spoken of officer in official conduct
  • Office of trust doctrine
  • Colloquium requirement for slander of officer

Legal principles applied

  • Words not actionable when spoken of common person may become actionable when spoken of officer in relation to official conduct
  • Statute of Glocester gives costs where damages recovered
  • Local statutes not applicable if not practiced upon in jurisdiction
Index terms93
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Substantive offenses
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
affirmed
Target
trial court judgment for plaintiff
Appealed from
Circuit Court judgment
Context
Court affirmed judgment for plaintiff with full costs, holding words actionable as slander when spoken of officer in official conduct
Scope
full
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
CranchKiltyMarshall
Courts
Locations
Statutes cited
Practice areas
Other index terms