Ludlow v. Bingham

Not specified
Decided Filed Not specifiedSupreme Court of Pennsylvania (High Court of Errors and Appeals)
Disposition
reversed
full scope · unanimous
Scan to open on mobileScan to open on another device
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Filed
Not specified
Decided
Judge
McKean, Chief Justice
Posture
Judgment entered for defendant by consent in Supreme Court to avoid delay, with writ of error brought
Plaintiff in error (indorsee of promissory note) (1)
Daniel Ludlow
Ingersoll, Dallas
v.
Defendant (maker of promissory note) (1)
Bingham
Lewis, E. Tilghman
Other parties: Henry Knox — Payee of promissory note, William Duer — Initial holder of promissory note, Nicholas Fish — Plaintiff in foreign attachment against Duer

Overview

The judgment below is reversed; judgment to be entered for Daniel Ludlow, the plaintiff in error. The attachment cannot be sustained, and the bearer of the note on the day of payment is entitled to recover the money from the drawer.

Case summary

This 1799 Pennsylvania case involves a promissory note made by Bingham payable to Henry Knox or order, dated in Philadelphia but delivered in New York to William Duer for valuable consideration. The note was endorsed in blank and circulated through multiple bona fide purchasers in New York, eventually reaching plaintiff Ludlow. Before these transfers, a foreign attachment was issued by Nicholas Fish against Duer and served on Bingham as garnishee. The central issues were whether the note was governed by Pennsylvania or New York law, and whether the attachment could defeat Ludlow's claim as a bona fide purchaser. The High Court of Errors and Appeals held unanimously that the note was governed by New York law where delivered, as delivery gave it life and negotiable character. The court also held that the attachment could not sustain against a bona fide purchaser without notice, as allowing such attachments would injure commercial circulation of negotiable instruments. The judgment for defendant was reversed and judgment entered for plaintiff.

Abstract

A promissory note payable to order was delivered in New York after being dated in Pennsylvania, endorsed in blank, and transferred to a bona fide purchaser through multiple bona fide holders. Before these transfers, a foreign attachment was served on the maker as garnishee in an action against an intermediate holder. The court held that New York law governed due to the place of delivery, which gave the note its life and negotiable character, and that the attachment could not defeat the rights of a bona fide purchaser without notice, as it would harm the commercial circulation of negotiable instruments; judgment was reversed for the plaintiff bearer.

Opinion of the court

Majority
opinion
McKean, Chief Justicejoined by Smith, Justice, Addison, Justice, Shippen, Justice, Rush, President Judge, Riddle, President Judge, Coxe, President Judge
  • Note governed by law of place of delivery (New York), not place of signing (Pennsylvania)
  • Attachment cannot defeat bona fide purchaser of negotiable note without notice
  • Commercial policy favors free circulation of negotiable instruments

Concurring opinions

3
Concurring Smith, Justice
Concurring Addison, Justice
Concurring Shippen, Justice

Jurisdiction

not challenged
Statutory basis
Not specified
Subject matter
Writ of error from Supreme Court of Pennsylvania to High Court of Errors and Appeals
Jurisdictional holding
Not applicable
Jurisdictional facts
  • Case involves promissory note and foreign attachment
  • Submitted for opinion of court on agreed facts

Procedural posture

Posture at trial
Judgment entered for defendant by consent in Supreme Court to avoid delay, with writ of error brought
Posture on appeal
Direct appeal via writ of error
Preserved issues
  • Whether promissory note governed by law of place of delivery
  • Whether foreign attachment can defeat bona fide purchaser of negotiable note

Subsequent history

Petition for rehearing
not filed
Rehearing en banc
not filed
Petition for certiorari
not filed
Remand proceedings
Judgment entered for plaintiff without remitting record to lower court
Mandate issued
Not specified
Subsequent citations
  • Tilden v. Blair, 21 Wall. 241
  • Ex parte Conrad, 8 Phila. 147
  • Wayne County Savings Bank v. Low, 81 N. Y. 566
  • Opdyke v. Merwin, 18 Hun 401
  • Weil v. Lange, 6 Daly 549
  • Bowen v. Bradley, 1 Sheld. 226
  • Hull v. Wheeler, 7 Abb. Pr. 411
  • Mott v. Wright, 4 Biss. 53

Legal categories

Business

Case record

Full case name
Ludlow, Plaintiff in error, v. Bingham
Docket number
Not specified
Court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania (High Court of Errors and Appeals)
Trial court
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Trial court judge
Not specified
Filed
Not specified
Decided
Opinion author
McKean, Chief Justice
Opinion type
published
Precedential status
precedential
Judges on panel
McKean, Chief JusticeShippen, JusticeSmith, JusticeRush, President JudgeRiddle, President JudgeAddison, President JudgeCoxe, President Judge

Issues & holdings

2
Issues raised
2
reversed
2
Holdings
Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Note receives life and negotiable character at place of delivery, so New York law applies

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Standard of review

de novo

Disposition rationale

Attachment cannot sustain against bona fide purchaser; would injure commercial circulation of negotiable instruments

Preservation

Issue preserved for review

Holdings of the court

Governing law of promissory note
Note is governed by law of New York where it was delivered, not Pennsylvania where it was signed
Note receives life, existence and negotiable character at place of delivery; bare signing without delivery does not give efficacy; delivery in New York made note take effect there
unanimousbinding precedent
Validity of foreign attachment against bona fide purchaser
Attachment cannot be sustained against subsequent bona fide purchaser of negotiable note for valuable consideration without notice
Money due on negotiable instrument cannot be attached before payable to defeat bona fide purchaser; would overthrow commercial system and annihilate negotiable quality; impractical to require purchaser to inquire about attachments given frequency of transfers and distance
unanimousbinding precedent

Error analysis

  • Trial court erred in allowing attachment to defeat bona fide purchaser of negotiable note — procedural · error foundNot applicable as error requires reversal · not harmless

Statutory interpretation

2
Statute
Pennsylvania act of assembly relating to promissory notes
Question
Whether act applies to note delivered and circulated out of state
Court's reading
Act does not apply as note governed by New York law where delivered
Canons applied
Lex loci contractusCommercial law principles
no legislative history
Statute
Attachment law of Pennsylvania
Question
Whether negotiable paper circulating abroad is within spirit and meaning of attachment law
Court's reading
Negotiable paper not within intent of attachment law when put into circulation out of state
Canons applied
ReasonablenessCommercial convenience
no legislative history

Burden of proof

Prosecution burden
Not applicable (civil case)
Defence burden
Not applicable

Standards of review

  • Conflict of laws and attachment validity — de novo Legal questions involving interpretation of contracts and commercial law reviewed de novo

Timeline

Procedural path

Promissory note createdNote deliveredForeign attachment issuedNote transferredWrit of inquiry executedAppellate argument
6
Events
2,222
Days, incident to ruling
—
Span
factual eventcited in opinion

Bingham makes promissory note payable to Henry Knox or order, dated in Philadelphia, payable at Bank of United States

Outcome: Note created but not delivered

Note signed but effectiveness depends on delivery

Conflict of lawsNegotiability of promissory note
Bingham · Henry Knox Philadelphia not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Note delivered in New York to William Duer pursuant to contract for valuable consideration (relinquishment of land contract rights)

Outcome: Note becomes binding contract

Delivery gives note life and makes it governed by New York law

Conflict of lawsValidity of note
Bingham · William Duer · Henry Knox New York not applicable
factual eventcited in opinion

Note passed from Duer to multiple bona fide purchasers in New York for valuable consideration without notice of attachment

Outcome: Note eventually becomes property of Ludlow

Note circulates in commerce as negotiable instrument

Attachment vs. bona fide purchaserNegotiability of promissory note
William Duer · Various purchasers · Daniel Ludlow New York not applicable
procedural eventcited in opinion

Foreign attachment issued by Nicholas Fish against William Duer, served on Bingham as garnishee

Outcome: Attachment served, judgment later entered for Fish

Attempt to secure debt due on note before maturity

Attachment vs. bona fide purchaserNegotiability of promissory note
Nicholas Fish · William Duer · Bingham Philadelphia trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Writ of inquiry executed in attachment, sum found due to Fish from Duer, judgment rendered

Outcome: Judgment for Fish remains in force

Attachment proceedings completed

Attachment vs. bona fide purchaser
Nicholas Fish · William Duer · Bingham Philadelphia trial court
procedural eventcited in opinion

Case argued before High Court of Errors and Appeals on writ of error

Outcome: Court delivers unanimous opinion

Appellate review of legal issues

All issues on appeal
Ingersoll · Dallas · Lewis · E. Tilghman · Judges Not specified appellate court

Facts & evidence

Incident

Date
End of December 1792
Location
Philadelphia and New York

Key facts

7 facts
  1. Defendant Bingham made promissory note payable to Henry Knox or order, dated in Philadelphia, payable at Bank of United States
  2. Note signed in Philadelphia but delivered in New York to William Duer for valuable consideration (relinquishment of land contract rights)
  3. Note endorsed in blank by Knox to Duer
  4. On May 11, 1793, foreign attachment issued by Nicholas Fish against Duer, served on Bingham as garnishee
  5. Note remained in Duer's possession until after attachment, then passed through multiple bona fide purchasers in New York for valuable consideration without notice of attachment
  6. Note eventually became property of plaintiff Ludlow
  7. In New York, promissory notes treated same as foreign bills of exchange under custom of merchants

Disputed questions

  • Whether note governed by Pennsylvania or New York law
  • Whether attachment valid against subsequent bona fide purchaser

Procedural history

4 steps
  1. Action by indorsee (Ludlow) against maker (Bingham) of promissory note
  2. Case submitted on agreed facts for court opinion
  3. Judgment entered for defendant by consent in Supreme Court
  4. Writ of error brought to High Court of Errors and Appeals

Evidence in the record

Direct
  • Promissory note itself
  • Agreed statement of facts submitted to court
Physical
  • Promissory note document
Documentary
  • Promissory note
  • Attachment records
  • Bank of United States documents
Circumstantial
  • Course of circulation of note through multiple purchasers

Objects of relevance

Promissory note document payable at Bank of United StatesBank notes as analogies to negotiable paper

Policy considerations

  • Commercial policy favoring free circulation of negotiable instruments
  • Importance of paper credit to national prosperity
  • Convenience and practicality in commercial transactions
  • Protection of bona fide purchasers to maintain confidence in commercial paper

Authorities

Cited authorities (3)

Kieifer v. Ehler, 18 Penn. St. 888
followedprecedent
Cited as authority that promissory note not yet due may be attached but not against bona fide indorsee without notice
at Not specified Held promissory note not yet due may be attached but attachment will not prevail against bona fide indorsee before maturity without notice
McCullough v. Houston, 1 Dall. 444
distinguisheddistinguished
Distinguished as involving different facts and later overruled
at Not specified Distinguished as involving equity between maker and payee under Pennsylvania act
McKim v. Elton
appliedprecedent
Cited for principle that mere signing without delivery gives note no effect
at Not specified Held mere signing without delivery gives note no effect

Related cases (4)

Kieifer v. Ehler, 18 Penn. St. 888
prior appeal
Held promissory note not yet due may be attached but attachment will not prevail against bona fide indorsee before maturity without notice
Hill v. Kraft, 29 Id 186
prior appeal
Cited as related authority
McCullough v. Houston, 1 Dall. 444
prior appeal
Distinguished; later overruled per Bullock v. Wicex, 7 Watts 329
McKim v. Elton
prior appeal
Held mere signing without delivery gives note no effect

Statutes

  • Pennsylvania act of assembly relating to promissory notes
  • Attachment law of Pennsylvania
  • Statute of Anne (3 & 4 Anne, c. 9) on promissory notes

Standards & doctrines

  • Lex loci deliveryis for negotiable instruments
  • Bona fide purchaser doctrine for commercial paper
  • Commercial law merchant principles

Legal principles applied

  • Delivery gives life to negotiable instrument
  • Commercial policy favors free circulation of negotiable paper
  • Attachment cannot alter negotiable nature of instrument

Notable quotes

“A note is not, therefore, obligatory and valid, until it has been actually delivered to the party, for whose use it is drawn ; and as it receives its life, existence and negotiable character, at the place where it is so delivered, the law of that place must regulate all its subsequent operations.”
McKean, Chief Justice — Discussion of where promissory note takes effect
Establishes lex loci deliveryis rule for negotiable instruments
“To adjudge that a note, which passes from hand to hand as cash... should be affected in this way, by a foreign attachment, would be, in effect, to overthrow an essential part of the commercial system, and to annihilate the negotiable quality of all such instruments.”
McKean, Chief Justice — Reasoning why attachment cannot defeat bona fide purchaser
Emphasizes commercial policy favoring free circulation of negotiable paper
Index terms107
Summary terms
Legal mechanisms
Various actions
Various actors
Legal concepts
Legal outcomes
Legal issues
Legal procedures
Legal remedies
Legal evidence
Legal arguments
Legal defenses
Legal penalties
Legal procedural steps
Geo locations
Judges
Attorneys
Procedural terms
Entities and documentation
Legal actions
Action type
reversed
Target
trial court judgment for defendant
Appealed from
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Citation
Not specified
Context
The judgment for the defendant must, therefore, be reversed; and judgment entered for the plaintiff.
Scope
full
Further instructions
Judgment to be entered for plaintiff without remitting record to lower court
Disposition vote
unanimous
Search facets
Parties
Judges
AddisonCoxeMckeanRiddleRushShippenSmith
Courts
Locations
Practice areas
Other index terms