Overview
Case summary
In M‘Cluny v. Silliman, the plaintiff sought a writ of mandamus from the U.S. Supreme Court to compel the defendant, a federal land-office register in Ohio, to enter the plaintiff's land application under the Act of May 10, 1800. The Ohio Supreme Court had previously refused the mandamus. The U.S. Supreme Court denied the motion, holding it lacked jurisdiction. Relying on Marbury v. Madison, the Court reasoned that issuing a mandamus to an officer for delivery of a paper constitutes original jurisdiction, not appellate jurisdiction, and the Judiciary Act of 1789 does not authorize such action. The Court distinguished cases where mandamus is issued to other federal courts, noting it had not decided whether it could issue mandamus to state courts.
Abstract
Plaintiff sought a writ of mandamus from the U.S. Supreme Court to compel a federal land-office register to enter a land application after denial by a state supreme court. The U.S. Supreme Court denied the motion, holding it lacked jurisdiction because issuing mandamus to a federal officer for delivery of a paper constitutes original jurisdiction not authorized by the Judiciary Act of 1789. The Court relied on Marbury v. Madison and distinguished mandamus issuance to federal versus state courts.
Opinion of the court
opinion
- Court lacks appellate jurisdiction to issue mandamus to federal officers for ministerial acts
- Issuing mandamus for delivery of a paper is equivalent to original jurisdiction
- Judiciary Act of 1789 does not authorize such jurisdiction
- Distinguishes cases where mandamus is issued to other federal courts
Jurisdiction
challenged- Case involves a writ of mandamus to a federal officer
- Mandamus refused by the Supreme Court of Ohio
- Defendant is the register of the land-office of the United States at Zanesville, Ohio
Procedural posture
- Jurisdiction to issue writ of mandamus to federal land-office register
Legal categories
Case record
Issues & holdings
de novo
Court lacks appellate jurisdiction because issuing such a writ would constitute original jurisdiction, which is not authorized
Issue preserved for review
Holdings of the court
Standards of review
- Jurisdiction to issue writ of mandamus — de novo Jurisdictional questions are reviewed de novo
Timeline
Procedural path
Mr. Harper moved for a mandamus in the U.S. Supreme Court to defendant Silliman as register of the land-office
Outcome: Motion denied
Court determined it lacked jurisdiction to issue the writ
Facts & evidence
Incident
Key facts
4 facts- Plaintiff sought a writ of mandamus to compel defendant, as register of the U.S. land-office, to enter plaintiff's application for certain tracts of land under the Act of May 10, 1800
- Defendant initially challenged jurisdiction of Ohio Supreme Court but waived plea
- Ohio Supreme Court discharged the rule and refused the mandamus
- Plaintiff now seeks mandamus from the U.S. Supreme Court
Procedural history
5 steps- Plaintiff obtained rule to show cause in Ohio Supreme Court
- Defendant appeared and excepted to jurisdiction but later waived plea
- Case agreed between parties
- Ohio Supreme Court ordered rule discharged
- Plaintiff moved for mandamus in U.S. Supreme Court
Authorities
Cited authorities (5)
Statutes
- Judiciary Act of 1789, 13th section
- Act of May 10, 1800, providing for sale of U.S. lands northwest of Ohio
Standards & doctrines
- De novo review for jurisdictional questions
- Political-process considerations in jurisdictional delegation
Legal principles applied
- Following Marbury v. Madison: mandamus to officer for delivery of paper is original jurisdiction, not appellate